OpenID for Verifiable Credential Issuance

For Authlete 2.x documentation, see 2.x version.

1. Introduction

This document explains the “OpenID for Verifiable Credential Issuance” (OID4VCI) specification and how Authlete supports the specification. This document elaborately explains overviews and details of various concepts, using well over 100 diagrams. All the explanations carefully avoid assuming prior knowledge of concepts not yet explained, allowing readers to understand the content without the need to navigate back and forth within the document. Additionally, the document refrains from delving into excessive details while presenting the overall picture to prevent readers from getting disoriented. These considerations make this document significantly more readable than the specification itself. Therefore, reading this document beforehand will be a great help when you read the specification.

Revision History
Date	Changes
2023-10-22	The initial version was published.
2023-10-27	Some subsections were added to the “OID4VCI Implementation” section.
2023-11-15	Some explanations and diagrams were updated to align with the specification changes below.
2023-11-24	The “OID4VCI Demo” section was added.Some explanations and diagrams were updated to align with the specification change below.
2023-12-30	A section for mdoc demo was added.Some explanations and diagrams were updated to align with the specification changes below.
2024-01-31	Updated to align with the specification changes below.
2024-02-03	Updated to align with the specification changes below.
2024-05-11	Added the “POTENTIAL Interop Event / Track 1 / Light Profile” section under the “OID4VCI Demo” section.
2024-06-05	Updated the “POTENTIAL Interop Event / Track 1 / Light Profile” section to reflect a bug fix for the mdoc payload. (cf. authlete/cbor PR 10)
2024-06-06	Added the “POTENTIAL Interop Event / Track 2 / Light Profile” section under the “OID4VCI Demo” section.
2024-06-11	Updated the “4.3.2.5. Step 5 : CWT Key Proof” section to reflect a bug fix in the format of `COSE_Key`.
2024-06-28	Added the “POTENTIAL Interop Event / Track 2 / Full Profile” section under the “OID4VCI Demo” section.

2. OID4VCI Specification

The OID4VCI specification defines rules for issuance of verifiable credentials.

2.1. Core Technical Terms

2.1.1. Verifiable Credential

“Verifiable credential” is a key technical term in the OID4VCI specification. “Credential” in the term represents a collection of data about a user or users (or any identifiable entities). Given name, family name, and birthdate are examples of data about a user. “Verifiable” in the term indicates that it is possible to verify that the data collection has not been tampered with. Technically speaking, it means that the data collection is digitally signed.

Digital driving licenses or health insurance cards stored on a mobile device are examples of verifiable credentials.

2.1.2. Credential Issuer

Verifiable credentials are issued by a “credential issuer”. Credential issuer is also a technical term. The specification describes behaviors of a credential issuer.

2.1.3. Access Token

To obtain a verifiable credential from a credential issuer, the requester of the issuance must present an “access token” to the credential issuer. The access token here is the one defined in RFC 6749, which is the core specification of OAuth 2.0.

2.1.4. Authorization Server

Access tokens are issued by an “authorization server”. The fundamental behaviors of an authorization server are defined in RFC 6749, and there are many other standard specifications around RFC 6749 that add extra functionalities to an authorization server. The OID4VCI specification also defines additional requirements for an authorization server so that an authorization server can issue access tokens that can be used for the issuance of verifiable credentials.

2.1.5. Wallet

In the OID4VCI specification, a software application that communicates with an authorization server and a credential issuer to obtain a verifiable credential is referred to as a “wallet”. Technically speaking, within the context of issuing verifiable credentials, a wallet acts as a “client application” of OAuth 2.0. Thus, from a technical perspective, the terms wallet and client application are interchangeable in the context of the OID4VCI specification.

However, please note that in the context of “OpenID for Verifiable Presentations”, which this document does not explain, a wallet acts as a server, not as a client application.

2.1.6. Relationship

The following diagram illustrates the relationship among the core technical terms.

2.2. Access Token Issuance Overview

2.2.1. Pre-Authorized Code Flow

The specification defines multiple methods for issuing access tokens that are usable for the issuance of verifiable credentials. One of these methods is entirely new. The new one is referred to as the “pre-authorized code flow”. In the flow, as the first step, a wallet obtains a “pre-authorized code” from a credential issuer.

Then, the wallet presents the pre-authorized code at the “token endpoint” (RFC 6749, 3.2. Token Endpoint) of an authorization server.

In return, the wallet receives an access token.

As explained in the previous section, the wallet presents the access token to the credential issuer. To be specific, the wallet presents the access token at the “credential endpoint” of the credential issuer.

In return, the wallet receives a verifiable credential.

The diagram below is an overview of the pre-authorized code flow.

2.2.2. Authorization Code Flow

The other methods than the pre-authorized code flow are extensions of the traditional “authorization code flow” (RFC 6749, 4.1. Authorization Code Grant). Let’s review the flow. In the authorization code flow, as the first step, a client application (which is a wallet in the OID4VCI context) sends an “authorization request” to the “authorization endpoint” (RFC 6749, 3.1. Authorization Endpoint) of an authorization server via a web browser.

On receiving the authorization request, the authorization server begins communicating with a user via the web browser. After obtaining consent from the user, the authorization server issues an “authorization code” to the client application.

Then, the client application sends a “token request” including the authorization code to the token endpoint of the authorization server.

In return, the client application receives an access token.

The process after getting an access token is the same as the one of the pre-authorized code flow. The client application presents the access token at the credential endpoint of the credential issuer.

In return, the client application receives a verifiable credential.

The diagram below illustrates the authorization code flow followed by the credential issuance.

The OID4VCI specification extends the authorization request in the authorization code flow. To be specific, the specification utilizes the following request parameters of an authorization request.

The issuer_state request parameter.
The authorization_details request parameter.
The scope request parameter.

The issuer_state request parameter is a new one defined by the OID4VCI specification. The authorization_details request parameter is defined in “RFC 9396 OAuth 2.0 Rich Authorization Requests”, a.k.a. “RAR”. The scope request parameter is a traditional one defined in “RFC 6749 The OAuth 2.0 Authorization Framework”.

As of this writing, the OID4VCI specification does not address the cases in which the above request parameters are used in combination. It remains uncertain whether the mechanisms using these request parameters are mutually exclusive or can coexist.Authlete’s current implementation considers all these mechanisms and generates an access token that can be used for the issuance of all the verifiable credentials requested via the request parameters.

2.2.3. Authorization Code Flow + issuer_state

The issuer_state request parameter is defined in the OID4VCI specification. To use the request parameter, a wallet needs to obtain an “issuer state” from a credential issuer before making an authorization request.

Then, the wallet makes an authorization request with the issuer state included as the value of the issuer_state request parameter.

The remaining part after the authorization request is the same as that of the normal authorization code flow.

The diagram below illustrates the authorization code flow with an issuer state.

2.2.4. Authorization Code Flow + authorization_details

The RAR specification (RFC 9396) defines the authorization_details parameter as a general-purpose parameter that conveys detailed information about authorization. It is up to deployments how to use the parameter. The value of the parameter is a JSON array, and each element of the array is a JSON object. We call the object “RAR object”.

Authorization Code Flow+authorization Details 1

The RAR object is flexible. Any properties can be put in the object. However, the RAR specification predefines several properties that are expected to be commonly used across the foreseeable use cases. Among such predefined properties, the "type" property is the only mandatory property. The property indicates what the RAR object represents. And, the OID4VCI specification defines a special value, "openid_credential", for the "type" property in order to indicate that the RAR object conveys information about the verifiable credential that the wallet wants.

Authorization Code Flow+authorization Details 2

2.2.5. Authorization Code Flow + scope

The scope request parameter is one of the traditional ones defined in the core specification of OAuth 2.0 (RFC 6749). Its original usage is to list permissions that the client application wants. If the user approves the request, the authorization server issues an access token that has the requested permissions.

Historically, the scope request parameter has been used for purposes beyond its original intent, and the OID4VCI specification has similarly extended the use of the scope request parameter. A credential issuer manages the types of verifiable credentials it can issue as “credential configurations”, and publishes the list of the credential configurations at a certain place. Each credential configuration may have a "scope" property.

A wallet may include values of the "scope" property in the scope request parameter to indicate which type of verifiable credentials it wants.

Multiple credential configurations may have the same value for the "scope" property.

Because the core specification of OAuth 2.0 (RFC 6749) requires that authorization servers ignore unknown scope values, it is likely that you need to explicitly pre-register the values of the "scope" property of the supported credentials as supported scope values with your authorization server.In addition, if OpenID Federation is employed, cares need to be taken to prevent metadata policies from dropping scope values for verifiable credential issuance unintentionally.

2.3. Credential Issuance Overview

Once a wallet obtains an access token from an authorization server, the wallet can request a credential issuer to issue a verifiable credential by presenting the access token. In the foundational procedure, the wallet sends a credential request with an access token to the credential endpoint of the credential issuer.

The credential issuer issues the requested verifiable credential as a response.

2.3.1. Deferred Credential Issuance

However, it is possible that the verifiable credential is not yet available when requested. For example, there might be time-consuming offline processes happening in the background. In such a case, the credential issuer issues a “transaction ID” instead.

In this case, the wallet waits until the verifiable credential issuance is ready. Then, it presents the previously received transaction ID and access token to the “deferred credential endpoint”.

The credential issuer issues the requested verifiable credential as a response.

If the verifiable credential is still not ready, the deferred credential endpoint will return an error indicating it (e.g., "error":"issuance_pending"). In this case, the wallet will make a “deferred credential request” again later.

2.3.2. Batch Credential Issuance

The wallet may want to obtain multiple verifiable credentials at a time. For such use cases, there is a “batch credential endpoint”. The wallet sends a “batch credential request” with an access token to the batch credential endpoint.

The endpoint returns multiple verifiable credentials and/or transaction IDs.

Each transaction ID can be used to obtain a verifiable credential from the deferred credential endpoint.

2.4. Access Token Issuance Details

In the previous sections, we’ve provided an overview of access token issuance and credential issuance. In this section, we will delve into the technical details of access token issuance.

2.4.1. Credential Offer

When a credential issuer issues a pre-authorized code, it provides a “credential offer” that includes the pre-authorized code instead of issuing it directly.

Likewise, an issuer state is also included as part of a credential offer. A credential offer may contain either a pre-authorized code, an issuer state, or both.

A credential offer contains other information, too. It always contains the identifier of the credential issuer.

Also, a credential offer contains information about the verifiable credentials that the credential issuer offers.

2.4.1.1. Credential Offer Issuance by Value

To transmit the credential offer to the wallet, a URL is employed. This URL is a “credential offer endpoint” with a query parameter credential_offer. The value of the query parameter is the content of the credential offer.

If the URL is accessed in some way and the access can be processed by the wallet, the wallet can receive the credential offer. However, a key issue here is how to trigger the access. The OID4VCI specification anticipates an HTTP GET request or HTTP redirection initiated by the credential issuer, but it does not define how the credential issuer and the wallet should agree upon the method of triggering the access. Another issue is that the credential issuer will not be able to know the value of the credential offer endpoint when providing a credential offer. The specification defines a client metadata called credential_offer_endpoint, which represents the wallet’s credential offer endpoint. However, especially in cases where a QR code representing the URL is used as suggested by the specification, the credential issuer do not have access to the wallet’s metadata because the credential issuer cannot know for which wallet it is going to provide a credential offer. For such cases, openid-credential-offer:// is defined as the fallback credential offer endpoint.

For the reasons mentioned above, credential issuers will implement the generation and transmission of the credential offer in their respective custom ways. Therefore, interoperability cannot be expected to a great extent.

2.4.1.2. Credential Offer Issuance by Reference

A credential offer may be passed to the wallet by reference. To be specific, the URL may contain the location of the issued credential offer instead of its content. In that case, a credential_offer_uri query parameter is used to point to the location.

The value of the credential_offer_uri query parameter points to an endpoint that returns the content of the issued credential offer.

By accessing the URI,

the wallet can obtain the content of the issued credential offer.

2.4.1.3. Credential Offer Content

The actual content of a credential offer is a JSON object.

The identifier of the credential issuer is put as the value of the "credential_issuer" property.

The information about the verifiable credentials that the credential issuer offers is put in the "credential_configuration_ids" array. The specific details of the array elements are discussed later.

When issued, an issuer state is placed at a somewhat nested location. There is a "grants" property as a top-level property in a credential offer. The value of the "grants" property is a JSON object. The keys within the "grants" JSON object are identifiers of grant types, such as authorization_code. The value of each entry in the "grants" JSON object is another JSON object containing properties related to the grant type represented by the corresponding key. In the case of the issuer state, the value of the issued issuer state is placed as the value of the "issuer_state" property within the "authorization_code" JSON object, which is within the "grants" JSON object.

Similarly, in the case of the pre-authorized code, the value of the issued pre-authorized code is placed as the value of the "pre-authorized_code" property within the "urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code" JSON object, which is within the "grants" JSON object. The string "urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code" here is the new identifier assigned to the pre-authorized code flow.

The "urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code" JSON object may contain a "tx_code" JSON object, which contains information about a “transaction code”. When the property is provided, the token request using the pre-authorized code will have to include a transaction code. Further details about this are described later.

The diagram below illustrates an overview of the structure of the content of a credential offer.

2.4.1.4. “credential_configuration_ids” in Credential Offer

The "credential_configuration_ids" property in a credential offer holds information about the verifiable credentials that the credential issuer offers. The value of the property is a JSON array. The elements in the array are strings. The values of the elements are the identifiers of the credential configurations.

Credential Offer Credential Configuration Ids

2.4.2. Pre-Authorized Code Flow Details

Once a wallet obtains a pre-authorized code, it can make a token request with the pre-authorized code. The table below lists the request parameters required for a token request to comply with the pre-authorized code flow.

Parameter	Description
`grant_type`	The value must be `"urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code"`.
`pre-authorized_code`	A pre-authorized code.
`tx_code`	A transaction code. Required if a credential offer contains a `tx_code` object.

The tx_code parameter is required if the pre-authorized code has been issued with a tx_code object like below. In this case, it is expected that the user will receive a transaction code corresponding to the pre-authorized code through some out-of-band mechanism.

{
  "credential_issuer": "...",
  "credential_configuration_ids": [
    "..."
  ],
  "grants": {
    "urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code": {
      "pre-authorized_code": "...",
      "tx_code": {
        "length": 6,
        "input_mode": "numeric",
        "description": "Input the one-time code sent via email"
      }
    }
  }
}

The tx_code object may contain the following parameters to help the wallet prepare a UI component for the user to input the transaction code.

Parameter	Description
`length`	The length of the transaction code.
`input_mode`	The input mode for the transaction code. The pre-defined values are `"numeric"` and `"text"`.
`description`	The information regarding the transaction code, such as the delivery channel.

Also, additional request parameters related to client authentication may be required. For example, when the private_key_jwt client authentication is employed, the client_assertion and client_assertion_type request parameters are required.

One ambitious attempt of the OID4VCI specification is that, depending on the configuration of the authorization server (to be specific, when the pre-authorized_grant_anonymous_access_supported server metadata is true), in the pre-authorized code flow, it may be permissible to make token requests that do not contain any information to identify the client application. If such a token request were actually made, an access token not associated with a specific client application would be issued.

The following is an example of a token request without client authentication using the pre-authorized code flow, excerpted from the OID4VCI specification.

POST /token HTTP/1.1
Host: server.example.com
Content-Type: application/x-www-form-urlencoded

grant_type=urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code
&pre-authorized_code=SplxlOBeZQQYbYS6WxSbIA
&tx_code=493536

The token endpoint will return a response including an access token as usual. The following is an example of token response excerpted from the specification.

HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Content-Type: application/json
Cache-Control: no-store

{
  "access_token": "eyJhbGciOiJSUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6Ikp..sHQ",
  "token_type": "bearer",
  "expires_in": 86400,
  "c_nonce": "tZignsnFbp",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

As the example above shows, when the issued access token can be used for the issuance of verifiable credentials, the token response may contain the c_nonce and c_nonce_expires_in response parameters, in addition to the traditional response parameters (access_token, token_type and expires_in) defined in the core specification of OAuth 2.0 (RFC 6749). Further details regarding these response parameters will be explained later.

2.4.3. Issuable Credentials

While there are multiple methods available to issue access tokens for verifiable credentials, from the perspective of access token implementation, they all converge on one common goal. That is to associate information about the types of verifiable credentials that can be issued with the access token. In this document, we call such information “issuable credential”. But, please keep in mind that “issuable credential” is not an official term. Elements in the "credential_configuration_ids" array in a credential offer are JSON strings. They indirectly specify issuable credentials by referencing credential configurations.

The number of elements in the "credential_configuration_ids" array in this example is one, but the array may contain multiple elements. Such elements compose the set of issuable credentials represented by the credential offer.

Therefore, it can be said that a token request using the pre-authorized code flow requests an access token associated with the issuable credentials specified in the credential offer that contains the pre-authorized code.

Similarly, it can be said that an authorization request with the issuer_state request parameter requests an access token associated with the issuable credentials specified in the credential offer that contains the issuer state.

A RAR object with "type":"openid_credential" may specify a credential configuration using the "credential_configuration_id" property as the base of an issuable credential.

A RAR object with the openid_credential type may use the format property instead.

In a RAR object with the openid_credential type, the credential_configuration_id property and the format property are mutually exclusive.

Values in the scope request parameter may indirectly specify one or more issuable credentials via the "scope" property of credential configurations.

Although the current draft of the OID4VCI specification does not explicitly address the cases where these mechanisms to specify issuable credentials are used simultaneously, in our interpretation and implementation, all the issuable credentials specified by these mechanisms are combined into a single set.

The diagram below illustrates the overall picture of the mechanisms to specify issuable credentials.

You might be curious about the structures of the credential information and the RAR object in the diagram.

However, before delving into those specifics, we need to walk through the formats of verifiable credentials.

2.5. Credential Verification

In order to discuss the formats of verifiable credentials, we need to understand their intended purpose. Let’s examine the verification steps of a verifiable credential, one by one. First, the credential issuer prepares data to include in a verifiable credential. In this example, we use name, birthdate, and address.

To sign the data, the credential issuer prepares a pair of a private key and a public key.

Then, the credential issuer signs the data with the private key. As a result, a signature is generated.

The set of the data and the signature is a verifiable credential.

The credential issuer passes the verifiable credential to the wallet.

If the wallet wants to verify the signature of the verifiable credential, it obtains the public key from the credential issuer through some means or other, and uses it to verify the signature. If the verification succeeds, it can be ensured that the verifiable credential has been issued by the legitimate credential issuer and the content has not been tampered with.

The key distinction between the use of a verifiable credential and an ID token is that the “holder” of a verifiable credential may present it to others. Before presented, a verifiable credential is transformed into a “verifiable presentation”.

However, from a technical perspective, it is possible for a verifiable credential and its corresponding verifiable presentation to be exactly identical.

The wallet presents the verifiable presentation to others. The external entities receiving the verifiable presentation are referred to as “verifiers” because they are supposed to verify the verifiable presentation before providing services to the holder.

If the verifier wants to verify the signature of the verifiable presentation, it obtains the public key from the credential issuer through some means or other, and uses it to verify the signature.

2.5.1. Key Binding

By the way, how can a verifier confirm the following?

The verifiable presentation has been presented by the holder.
The verifiable credential underlying the verifiable presentation has been issued by the credential issuer to the holder.

As for the first point, it can be achieved by having the holder provide a pair of a private key and a public key,

and including a signature made with the holder’s private key in the verifiable presentation. The target data for the signature can be arbitrary as long as the data is presented together with the signature.

As for the second point, it can be achieved by including the holder’s public key in the verifiable credential’s data and having the credential issuer sign the entire data with its private key.

The cryptographic association between the verifiable credential and the holder in this manner is referred to as “key binding”.

Strictly speaking, the public key used for the key binding mechanism is not always bound to the holder. Instead, it may be bound to one of the devices managed by the holder or even a device that may not be directly managed by the holder. Considering these cases, this mechanism is no longer referred to as “holder binding”.

When the wallet requests a verifiable credential with cryptographic key binding, it includes the public key in the credential request. However, the credential issuer should not unconditionally accept the presented public key, as a malicious wallet could present an irrelevant public key. Therefore, the wallet must demonstrate the legitimate ownership of the public key. To achieve this, the wallet generates a signature using the private key and presents it alongside the public key. This combination of the signature and the public key is commonly known as a “key proof”.

If the credential issuer can validate the presented public key, it can create a verifiable credential with key binding.

The verifiable credential is then passed to the wallet,

which uses it to create a verifiable presentation. The wallet includes a signature created using the private key in the verifiable presentation.

The verifiable presentation is then passed to the verifier.

The verifier can verify the signature added by the wallet by using the public key embedded in the verifiable presentation.

The following diagram illustrates the overall picture of the credential verification explained so far.

2.6. Selective Disclosure

When presenting a verifiable presentation, the holder may choose to disclose only certain parts of the verifiable credential’s content. For example, if the verifiable credential contains name, birthdate, and address, the holder may opt to disclose only the name and birthdate while omitting the address information. We call the act of selectively disclosing chosen information like this “selective disclosure”.

However, omitting information without special consideration will result in the failure of the signature verification. This is because the dataset targeted for signing differs from the dataset received by the verifier.

There are several methods to achieve selective disclosure without invalidating the signature. BBS+ (Boneh-Lynn-Shacham signature plus) and CL Signatures (Camenisch-Lysyanskaya Signatures) are examples and may seem promising. However, in the real world, the adoption of these methods depends on various factors, as outlined below, and it is not always the case that solutions based on academically elegant theories become widespread:

The complexity of the theory.
The ease of implementation.
Monetary costs for licensing.
Legal restrictions on usage.
Support from Hardware Security Module (HSM) products.
How much the industry believes the algorithm is robust/secure.

After thorough comparison of credential profiles and hackathons, the industry has decided to create a new format called “Selective Disclosure for JWTs (SD-JWT)“.

2.6.1. SD-JWT

SD-JWT is a format that utilizes JWT (RFC 7519 JSON Web Token (JWT)) to achieve selective disclosure. The payload part of a normal JWT contains pairs of a claim name and its value.

To make such a claim “selectively-disclosable” using the SD-JWT format, you first extract the claim.

Then, you add an arbitrary salt to it,

and create a JSON array including the salt, the claim name and the claim value.

The next step is to encode that JSON array in base64url. In the SD-JWT specification, the resulting string is referred to as “disclosure”.

The original claim is replaced with the digest value of the disclosure. The digest value is base64url-encoded and placed in the "_sd" array, which is inserted where the original claim was located.

The same process is applied to other claims that need to be made selectively-disclosable.

By concatenating the “issuer-signed JWT” with the disclosures using tildes (~), a single string is formed.

This resulting string is an SD-JWT.

The next step is optional, but if you want to perform key binding, please prepare a key pair.

Then, embed the public key into the issuer-signed JWT,

Instead of embedding the public key, a reference to it may be included.

sign a specific dataset defined in the specification, and place the resulting JWT at the end of the previously created SD-JWT. The JWT is called “key binding JWT”.

Note that the responsibility for generating a key binding JWT lies with the holder/wallet, not the credential issuer. Therefore, even if the verifiable credential format is based on SD-JWT, the verifiable credential does not include a key binding JWT when it is issued by the credential issuer.

The following diagram illustrates the overall process of generating SD-JWT that we have explained so far.

The key point is that if the recipient of an SD-JWT doesn’t receive all the disclosures, they can only reconstruct claims corresponding to the received disclosures. Importantly, even in the case, the signature of the issuer-signed JWT remains valid.

For more detailed information, please refer to the SD-JWT specification itself. Additionally, you can find useful information in the README of the open-source SD-JWT library for the Java programming language, authlete/sd-jwt.

2.7. Verifiable Credential Formats

2.7.1. Confusion Surrounding Verifiable Credential Formats

The confusion surrounding verifiable credential formats stems from the existence of multiple competing specifications, each with its own set of challenges, and many of which are still in development. Furthermore, the fact that organizations from various countries, regions, and industries are promoting different formats is also complicating the situation. When it comes to verifiable credentials, many people associate them with the “W3C Verifiable Credentials Data Model” (W3C VCDM). This is primarily because the document is often seen as the primary source defining the three-party Issuer-Holder-Verifier model. However, W3C VCDM itself is not flawless, and discussions are indeed ongoing. While version 1.1 was released on March 3, 2022, version 2.0 is currently under discussion. When observed from an external perspective, what further complicates the situation is the specification titled “Securing Verifiable Credentials using JOSE and COSE” (w3c/vc-jose-cose). The specification states in the “Abstract” section that it “defines how to secure credentials and presentations conforming to the VC-DATA-MODEL”, but it conflicts with certain requirements of W3C VCDM. For instance, W3C VCDM mandates that the value of the "typ" header parameter must be "JWT", but this requirement is not followed by w3c/vc-jose-cose. Additionally, W3C VCDM introduces the "vc" and "vp" claims as the designated places to embed verifiable credentials and verifiable presentations. However, w3c/vc-jose-cose does not utilize these "vc" and "vp" claims. Furthermore, what adds to the confusion for newcomers is that the OID4VCI specification defines jwt_vc_json, jwt_vc_json-ld, and ldp_vc as credential format profiles based on W3C VCDM, but most people in the OpenID industry contributing to the specification do not seem inclined to support these credential format profiles. They are currently dedicating their efforts to the specification development and implementation of verifiable credential formats based on SD-JWT and “ISO/IEC 18013-5” (Personal identification - ISO-compliant driving licence - Part 5: Mobile driving licence (mDL) application). For those discussing OAuth and OpenID Connect, ISO/IEC 18013-5 is challenging to approach because its format is based on the less familiar binary format, “Concise Binary Object Representation” (CBOR) (RFC 8949) and “CBOR Object Signing and Encryption” (COSE) (RFC 9052, RFC 9053). Additionally, detailed technical articles about it are not widely available online because ISO standards must be purchased. The public key distribution method for verifying verifiable credentials is also a challenging issue. When a verifier receives a verifiable credential, they cannot determine whether it was issued according to the OID4VCI specification. Therefore, it is not ideal to force verifiers to search for public keys starting from the metadata of credential issuers (/.well-known/openid-credential-issuer). As an alternative starting point, the well-known path /.well-known/jwt-issuer was proposed in the specification called “SD-JWT-based Verifiable Credentials (SD-JWT VC)”. The path name has been renamed to /.well-known/jwt-vc-issuer later because the previous path name could easily clash with other JWT issuer-related specifications. However, the issue remains that the path name unnecessarily assumes that VC formats are based on JWT. Therefore, some people are not favorable to the solution. In fact, the Italian ecosystem that leverages OpenID Federation has opted not to use /.well-known/jwt-vc-issuer. Instead, they have chosen to define a new entity type identifier called openid_credential_issuer and embed public keys for verifiable credential verification in the "metadata"."openid_credential_issuer" object of the entity configuration. As a related topic, a new client authentication method called “OAuth 2.0 Attestation-Based Client Authentication” is currently under development. For the method, a wallet must obtain a “wallet attestation” from an “attester” in advance because the wallet needs to include this attestation when performing the client authentication method. The recipient (e.g., an authorization server) of the attestation must obtain the public key for verifying the attestation’s signature from the attester. Here, the distribution of public keys for attestations is an issue similar to that described for verifiable credentials above. And, here again, /.well-known/jwt-vc-issuer is proposed as a possible option. This is the very predicted concern, which makes it technically impossible to run an attester and a credential issuer on the same server (but whether running both on the same server is conceptually suitable or not is a different matter). Additionally, whether the attestation format is JWT or not is not essential. However, a more serious issue regarding the attestation-based client authentication is that agreement on the basic concept has not been fully reached yet (cf. ISSUE 61).

2.7.2. Essential Functions of Verifiable Credential Formats

As mentioned in the previous section, there are many challenges related to verifiable credential formats. However, we believe that the essential functions expected from verifiable credential formats can be summarized as follows:

Verifiability
Key Binding
Selective Disclosure

In the following section, we will explain a verifiable credential format based on SD-JWT that can meet these requirements.

2.7.3. SD-JWT VC

SD-JWT is a general-purpose data format and not a verifiable credential format in itself. However, by adding certain requirements, it is possible to define a verifiable credential format based on SD-JWT. “SD-JWT-based Verifiable Credentials (SD-JWT VC)” is a specification designed for this purpose. Since an overview of SD-JWT has already been provided, we will only briefly introduce the key points of SD-JWT VC in the following table. Please refer to the SD-JWT VC specification for more details.

Media Type	`application/vc+sd-jwt`
Issuer-signed JWT	Place	Name	Presence	Description
	Header	`alg`	REQUIRED	As required by the JWT specification (RFC 7519).
	Header	`typ`	REQUIRED	`vc+sd-jwt`
	Payload	`iss`	REQUIRED	The identifier of the credential issuer.
		`iat`	REQUIRED	The issuance time.
		`nbf`	OPTIONAL	The time before which the verifiable credential must not be accepted.
		`exp`	OPTIONAL	The expiry time.
		`cnf`	CONDITIONALLY REQUIRED	Required when cryptographic key binding is to be supported. The `"jwk"` property representing the public key should be included. (cf. RFC 7800)
		`vct`	REQUIRED	The identifier of the type of the verifiable credential.
		`status`	OPTIONAL	The information on how to read the status of the verifiable credential.
		`sub`	OPTIONAL	The identifier of the subject of the verifiable credential.
Key Binding JWT	Place	Name	Presence	Description
	Header	`alg`	REQUIRED	As required by the JWT specification (RFC 7519).
	Header	`typ`	REQUIRED	`kb+jwt` (as required by the SD-JWT specification)
	Payload	`iat`	REQUIRED	The issuance time.
		`aud`	REQUIRED	The intended recipient of the key binding JWT, which is typically the verifier.
		`nonce`	REQUIRED	A string ensuring the freshness of the signature.
		`sd_hash`	REQUIRED	The base64url-encoded hash digest over the issuer-signed JWT and the selected disclosures.

The actual value of the vct claim and additional claims specific to the credential type in the issuer-signed JWT are determined by respective deployments, and they fall outside the scope of the SD-JWT VC specification.

2.7.4. Other Verifiable Credential Formats

This document does not describe other verifiable credential formats such as jwt_vc_json.

2.8. Credential Information for Access Token

Since we have covered verifiable credential formats, we can revisit the topic of credential information for access tokens.

2.8.1. Credential Information in RAR Object

When the type of a RAR object is "openid_credential", the RAR object contains information about an issuable credential. Such RAR object must contain either the credential_configuration_id property or the format property. These two properties are mutually exclusive.

2.8.1.1. RAR Object with The `credential_configuration_id` Property

The value of the credential_configuration_id property points to an entry in the credential configurations in the credential issuer metadata.

While not explicitly explained in the specification, the examples within it imply that the credential configuration pointed to by the credential_configuration_id property is used just as the base for constructing an issuable credential. Put differently, the examples imply that, unlike the credential configurations referenced in a credential offer, the credential configuration referenced in a RAR object is used solely to gather information about the credential format (along with other mandatory properties, such as vct in the case of the vc+sd-jwt format and doctype in the case of the mso_mdoc format). Consequently, the RAR object is expected to include a list of claims that the wallet wants to get. The method of listing claims varies depending on the format of the credential. For example, according to the examples in the specification, the jwt_vc_json format uses a "credential_definition" property to list up claims.

{
  "type": "openid_credential",
  "credential_configuration_id": "UniversityDegreeCredential",
  "credential_definition": {
    "credentialSubject": {
      "given_name": {},
      "family_name": {},
      "degree": {}
    }
  }
}

On the other hand, the mso_mdoc format uses a "claims" property.

{
  "type": "openid_credential",
  "credential_configuration_id": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
  "claims": {
    "org.iso.18013.5.1": {
      "given_name": {},
      "family_name": {},
      "birth_date": {}
    },
    "org.iso.18013.5.1.aamva": {
      "organ_donor": {}
    }
  }
}

2.8.1.2. RAR Object with The `format` Property

When the format property is used instead of the credential_configuration_id property, the RAR object needs to contain complete information about an issuable credential. In the example below, mso_mdoc is specified as the verifiable credential format. Consequently, the doctype property is also included as it is mandatory for this format.

{
  "type": "openid_credential",
  "format": "mso_mdoc",
  "doctype": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
  "claims": {
    "org.iso.18013.5.1": {
      "given_name": {},
      "family_name": {},
      "birth_date": {}
    },
    "org.iso.18013.5.1.aamva": {
      "organ_donor": {}
    }
  }
}

2.8.2. Credential Information in Credential Configuration

Information about credential configurationss is described as a part of “credential issuer metadata”. The metadata is a JSON object. It contains a credential_configurations_supported JSON object. Each of the entries in the object represents credential configuration about a verifiable credential supported by the credential issuer.

The properties within a credential configuration object are divided into (1) those that may appear common to all credential configuration objects and (2) those specific to the respective format. For example, the "format" property always exists in every credential configuration object, while the claims property is available for some formats only.

2.9. Credential Issuance Details

The previous sections have covered the details about access token issuance. Next, we will delve into the details about credential issuance.

2.9.1. Key Proof

As explained in the “Credential Verification” section, the wallet is expected to provide a key proof if it wishes to obtain a verifiable credential capable of key binding.

In the OID4VCI specification, three specific formats for key proof are defined. These formats are based on JWT (RFC 7519), CWT (RFC 8392), and Data Integrity (Data Integrity), respectively. Additional key proof formats may be introduced in the future when the need arises.

2.9.1.1. Key Proof JWT

By definition, a key proof includes a public key or a reference to the key. In the case of the key proof based on JWT, several methods are employed to include this key information as listed below. A key proof JWT must use one and only one of the methods.

The jwk header parameter (RFC 7515, 4.1.3)
The x5c header parameter (RFC 7515, 4.1.6)
The kid header parameter (RFC 7515, 4.1.4)

The current draft of the OID4VCI specification may give the impression that the combination of the kid and trust_chain header parameters can specify a public key for key binding. However, the combination won’t work unless supplementary rules and mechanisms are introduced.

All of these methods embed the key information in the header of a key proof JWT.

In the case of using the jwk header parameter, the public key is embedded in the format of “JWK” (RFC 7517 JSON Web Key (JWK)).

The value of the jwk header parameter is a JSON object representing the public key.

The key proof JWT itself must be signed with the private key that corresponds to the public key.

In the case of using the x5c header parameter, an X.509 certificate for the public key needs to be prepared. The base64 representation of the DER representation of the certificate must be included in the x5c JSON array as the first element. If the certificate chain of the certificate is available, the chain can be included along with the certificate. See RFC 7515, 4.1.6. “x5c” (X.509 Certificate Chain) Header Parameter for the details of the format that the x5c parameter expects.

In the case of using the kid header parameter, its value should be a DID URL that can be resolved to the public key.

Next, let’s take a look at the payload part of a key proof JWT.

The following table lists the claims that must or may appear in the payload part of a key proof JWT.

Name	Presence	Description
`iss`	CONDITIONALLY REQUIRED	The identifier of the client application (wallet).
`aud`	REQUIRED	The identifier of the credential issuer.
`iat`	REQUIRED	The issuance time.
`nonce`	CONDITIONALLY REQUIERD	The server-provided `c_nonce`.

The iss claim represents the identifier of the client application (wallet) and is required in most cases. The only exception is when the access token is issued using the pre-authorized code flow, and the token request for the access token doesn’t include any information to identify the client application. Such token requests are allowed only if the authorization server permits anonymous access in the pre-authorized code flow. The authorization server’s support for this is indicated by the boolean server metadata, pre-authorized_grant_anonymous_access_supported.
The aud claim represents the identifier of the credential issuer and is always required.
The iat claim represents the issuance time of the key proof JWT, as defined in RFC 7519, 4.1.6. “iat” (Issued At) Claim. This claim is always required.
The nonce claim corresponds to the c_nonce included in the token response and/or the credential response. It is required when the token response contains the c_nonce parameter. Additionally, the credential issuer may mandate the nonce claim, even when the token response doesn’t contain the c_nonce parameter. More information about c_nonce will be provided later.

The following table summarizes the requirements for a key proof JWT.

Key Proof JWT	Place	Name	Presence	Description
	Header	`alg`	REQUIRED	As required by the JWT specification (RFC 7519).
		`typ`	REQUIRED	`openid4vci-proof+jwt`
		`jwk`	CONDITIONALLY REQUIRED	Exactly one of these header parameters must be included, representing a public key or the reference to a public key.
		`x5c`
		`kid`
	Payload	`iss`	CONDITIONALLY REQUIRED	The identifier of the client application (wallet).
		`aud`	REQUIRED	The identifier of the credential issuer.
		`iat`	REQUIRED	The issuance time.
		`nonce`	CONDITIONALLY REQUIRED	The server-provided `c_nonce`.

The following is an example of key proof JWT.

eyJ0eXAiOiJvcGVuaWQ0dmNpLXByb29mK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7Imt0eSI6IkVDIiwiY3J2IjoiUC0yNTYiLCJraWQiOiJHVURvZFB1SURJYllocmdmMHZsT3RNd1otczNiaVpFT3hWMFRTRjBKN3R3IiwieCI6InJjdU1FT1BYbVBJRlotc0Jvbkxyb1VvaTVYdGZ4NktWeFlFR09YMi1UbGsiLCJ5IjoiNUw1SUZrUFpNT0doTVpsNHRaSk9ISjdtckZQbnJSeV9RSURUOXRWZF9obyIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2In19.eyJpc3MiOiJodHRwczovL3dhbGxldC5leGFtcGxlLmNvbSIsImF1ZCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vaXNzdWVyLmV4YW1wbGUuY29tIiwiaWF0IjoxNjk3MjM0NzcwLCJub25jZSI6IjZhMzA3YjU1LWM4ZTEtNDg4YS05NjFlLTI1MzQ4ZmYzZTlkYSJ9.Vvo_X_fZyanUZ-y5X0yYtY7d70bbjMKUKqAoDiCBmP3NT4xNfTEpuYl9eu7vxc2fLf67ZdbSfw4rwEp8qvvWpA

The header and payload of the key proof JWT example are decoded into the following JSONs, respectively.

{
  "alg": "ES256",
  "typ": "openid4vci-proof+jwt",
  "jwk": {
    "kty": "EC",
    "alg": "ES256",
    "crv": "P-256",
    "x":   "rcuMEOPXmPIFZ-sBonLroUoi5Xtfx6KVxYEGOX2-Tlk",
    "y":   "5L5IFkPZMOGhMZl4tZJOHJ7mrFPnrRy_QIDT9tVd_ho",
    "kid": "GUDodPuIDIbYhrgf0vlOtMwZ-s3biZEOxV0TSF0J7tw"
  }
}

{
  "iss": "https://wallet.example.com",
  "aud": "https://issuer.example.com",
  "iat": 1697234770,
  "nonce": "6a307b55-c8e1-488a-961e-25348ff3e9da"
}

2.9.1.2. Other Key Proofs

This document does not explain other key proofs such as CWT-based key proof. Please refer to the OID4VCI specification for them.

2.9.2. c_nonce

As the primary countermeasure against key proof replay, the credential issuer may require the inclusion of the nonce claim in the key proof. The value of this claim is provided as a c_nonce response parameter from the authorization server or the credential issuer. A token response from the authorization server may include the c_nonce response parameter along with the c_nonce_expires_in response parameter, which indicates the lifetime of the c_nonce in seconds.

The wallet uses the value of the c_nonce response parameter as the value of the nonce claim in a key proof JWT.

The wallet includes the key proof JWT in a credential request.

If the nonce claim is missing, although the credential issuer requires it, or if the specified nonce value has expired, the credential endpoint will return an error response. This error response includes either the expected c_nonce value or a fresh c_nonce value. Additionally, even when a valid nonce value is provided, the credential response may still include c_nonce for future use. In either case, c_nonce is included in a credential response if the credential issuer requires key proofs include the nonce claim.

If necessary, the wallet can regenerate a new key proof using the c_nonce value provided by the credential endpoint and make a credential request again with the fresh key proof.

The diagram below provides an overview of c_nonce.

2.9.3. Credential Request

A credential request is an HTTP POST request with an access token and a JSON-formatted payload. This payload contains credential information and may include an optional key proof.

A credential_response_encryption JSON object may be present for credential response encryption, but it is not discussed here.

2.9.3.1. Credential Information in Credential Request

Credential information in a credential request includes a mandatory "format" property and additional format-specific properties. For example, when the value of the "format" property is "jwt_vc_json", an accompanying "credential_definition" property is expected.

The credential information is a description about the verifiable credential that the wallet wants to obtain. As implied by the example in the diagram above, taken from the OID4VCI specification, this description goes beyond merely identifying an issuable credential from among the issuable credentials associated with the access token. For instance, the intention of the example credential request is to request a verifiable credential in the format of jwt_vc_json that includes the given_name, family_name and degree claims only. However, there are the following issues here:

It’s not easy to determine which of the issuable credentials meet the specified conditions.
There’s a possibility that multiple issuable credentials may satisfy the conditions.
Minor differences in conditions can lead to the selection of a different issuable credential.
It’s not easy to confirm whether the presented access token has the permission to request verifiable credentials that meet the specified conditions.

Simply put, this specification lacks considerations for implementations. The problem reported by Issue 175 is an example that can be caused by the flaw in this specification. Therefore, unless the specification is improved, it is likely that credential issuer implementations will issue verifiable credentials with fixed structures, ignoring finer conditions specified at runtime (in access token requests or credential requests).

The OID4VCI has recently introduced the credential_identifier parameter that is mutually exclusive with the format parameter. However, such credential instance identifiers become available (if the credential issuer supports the mechanism) only when RAR objects of type openid_credential are used, and the specification says that the credential instance identifiers cannot be used when the scope parameter is used. The credential_identifier parameter is a solution designed solely for a specific use case and does not serve as a resolution for the issue mentioned above. See Issue 197 for further discussions.

2.9.3.2. Key Proof Information in Credential Request

Key proof information in a credential request is represented by a "proof" property. The value of the property is a JSON object.

The "proof" object contains a mandatory "proof_type" property that indicates the format of the key proof. When the value of the "proof_type" property is "jwt", a JWT is used as a key proof. In this case, the "proof" object contains a "jwt" property. The value of the "jwt" property is a JWT that conforms to the specification of the key proof JWT.

The diagram below is an overview of a credential request.

2.9.4. Credential Response

A credential response is an HTTP response containing JSON.

2.9.4.1. Credential Response with Verifiable Credential

When a verifiable credential is successfully issued, it is placed in the JSON as the value of the "credential" property.

For instance, in the case of SD-JWT-based verifiable credentials conforming to SD-JWT VC, the "credential" property is a JSON string in the format of SD-JWT.

In addition, the credential response may contain the c_nonce and c_nonce_expires_in response parameters, as explained previously.

Let’s dive into some details of an SD-JWT-based verifiable credential.

An SD-JWT consists of an issuer-signed JWT, zero or more disclosures, and an optional key binding JWT. Tildes (~) are used as delimiters between the components. Note that because a key binding JWT is generated by a wallet, verifiable credentials do not have a key binding JWT when they are issued by a credential issuer.

<Issuer-Signed-JWT>~<Disclosure-1>...<Disclosure-N>~

The first component in an SD-JWT is an issuer-signed JWT. As a standard JWT, the header and payload of the issuer-signed JWT can be base64url-decoded.

The following are important points to note.

The value of the typ header parameter is "vc+sd-jwt".
The payload contains "cnf"."jwk" for key binding.
The payload contains the "_sd_alg" property, which indicates the hash algorithm used for disclosures.
The payload does not contain user claims like "given_name". Instead, it contains the "_sd" array, which holds digest values of disclosures for user claims.

The example of SD-JWT-based verifiable credential contains four disclosures.

By base64url-decoding the disclosures, the original JSON arrays will appear.

The digest values of the disclosures are computed using the hash algorithm indicated by the "_sd_alg" property and are listed in the "_sd" array. The order of the digest values in the array must be independent of the order of the disclosures in the SD-JWT. In this example, the digest values are listed in ASCII-code order.

The diagram below is an overview of a credential response with an SD-JWT-based verifiable credential.

2.9.4.2. Credential Response with Transaction ID

When the requested verifiable credential is not ready, the credential endpoint returns a transaction ID instead of a verifiable credential. The transaction ID is included in the credential response as the value of the "transaction_id" response parameter. The following is an example from the OID4VCI specification.

HTTP/1.1 202 Accepted
Content-Type: application/json
Cache-Control: no-store

{
  "transaction_id": "8xLOxBtZp8",
  "c_nonce": "wlbQc6pCJp",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

The transaction ID is intended to be used later when the wallet sends a deferred credential request to the deferred credential endpoint of the credential issuer.

2.9.4.3. Credential Response with Error

If the credential request cannot be processed successfully, the credential endpoint will return an error response, with the type of error reflected in the value of the "error" response parameter. Below is a sample error excerpt from the specification.

HTTP/1.1 400 Bad Request
Content-Type: application/json
Cache-Control: no-store

{
   "error": "invalid_request"
}

If a required key proof is missing or incorrect due to reasons like the nonce claim’s absence or expiration, the error code "invalid_proof" is used. Here is an example from the specification in such a case.

HTTP/1.1 400 Bad Request
Content-Type: application/json
Cache-Control: no-store

{
  "error": "invalid_proof",
  "error_description":
    "Credential Issuer requires key proof to be bound to a Credential Issuer provided nonce.",
  "c_nonce": "8YE9hCnyV2",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

2.9.5. Deferred Credential Request

The wallet can send a request to the deferred credential endpoint using a transaction ID. This request should be an HTTP POST request containing JSON with a "transaction_id" property holding the transaction ID.

POST /deferred_credential HTTP/1.1
Host: issuer.example.com
Content-Type: application/json
Authorization: Bearer czZCaGRSa3F0MzpnWDFmQmF0M2JW

{
   "transaction_id": "8xLOxBtZp8"
}

2.9.6. Deferred Credential Response

The deferred credential endpoint will respond with an HTTP response containing JSON. If a verifiable credential has been issued successfully, this JSON includes the "credential" response parameter, representing the verifiable credential.

HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Content-Type: application/json
Cache-Control: no-store

{
  "credential": "eyJ......CJd~"
}

In the event of an unsuccessful issuance, an error response will be returned with the "error" parameter. Particularly, when the requested verifiable credential is not yet ready, the error code "issuance_pending" is used.

HTTP/1.1 400 Bad Request
Content-Type: application/json
Cache-Control: no-store

{
   "error": "issuance_pending"
}

2.9.7. Batch Credential Request

A wallet can request multiple verifiable credentials at a time by sending a batch credential request to the batch credential endpoint of the credential issuer. A batch credential request is an HTTP POST request containing JSON, which includes a "credential_requests" JSON array. The array is a list of JSON objects, each of which represents a credential request.

Each credential request contains credential information and may contain an optional key proof.

It is allowed for credential requests in a batch credential request to specify different credential formats and have different key proofs. The opposite is also true. The credential requests may specify the same credential format and have the same key proof.

The diagram below is an overview of a batch credential request.

2.9.8. Batch Credential Response

A batch credential response is an HTTP response containing JSON, which includes a "credential_responses" JSON array. The array is a list of JSON objects, each of which represents a credential response. The elements in the array correspond to the elements in the "credential_requests" array in the preceding batch credential request.

Each credential response contains either a verifiable credential or a transaction ID.

In addition, a batch credential response may contain c_nonce and c_nonce_expires_in as top-level properties for cases where the wallet sends a credential request or a batch credential request with a key proof in the future.

The diagram below is an overview of a batch credential response.

2.10. Public Key Distribution

To verify the signature of a verifiable credential or a verifiable presentation, verifiers need to obtain the public key that corresponds to the private key which the credential issuer used to sign the verifiable credential. How to distribute public keys for verifying the signatures of verifiable credentials is outside the scope of the OID4VCI specification. However, here we describe a few proposed methods.

2.10.1. Embedding X.509 Certificate

One method for public key distribution is to embed an X.509 certificate for the public key within the verifiable credential. In the case of JWT-based verifiable credentials, it is likely that the "x5c" header parameter (RFC 7515, 4.1.6) will be used for that purpose.

2.10.2. Embedding within Entity Configuration

Another method utilizes the OpenID Federation specification and embeds the public key within the entity configuration of the credential issuer. The Italian ecosystem has defined openid_credential_issuer as a new entity type identifier, which represents a credential issuer, and the ecosystem uses the "jwks" metadata to place the credential issuer’s public keys within.

At the time of this writing, "jwks", "jwks_uri", and "signed_jwks_uri" have not been defined as credential issuer metadata.

2.10.3. jwt-vc-issuer

Another proposal for public key distribution is /.well-known/jwt-vc-issuer. The new well-known path is intended to serve as the starting point for searching for the public key.

The well-known path returns JSON containing the JWT VC issuer’s metadata. The "jwks_uri" property in the JSON points to the location of the JWK Set of the issuer. Verifiers can find the target public key in the JWK Set.

The JWT VC issuer metadata may contain the "jwks" property rather than the "jwks_uri" property. This can happen when the JWT VC issuer has a difficulty in providing a separate endpoint for its JWK Set for various reasons.

2.11. Specification Summary

The OID4VCI specification defines rules for the issuance of verifiable credentials. The two major topics in the specification are “access token issuance” and “credential issuance”. For access token issuance, the specification defines several methods for specifying issuable credentials, which include, (1) using the pre-authorized code in a credential offer, (2) using the issuer state in a credential offer, (3) using RAR objects with "type":"openid_credential", and (4) using scope values referencing entries in the credential_configurations_supported metadata. For credential issuance, the specification introduces three endpoints, namely, (1) the credential endpoint, (2) the batch credential endpoint, and (3) the deferred credential endpoint. Pieces of credential information appear at some locations such as (1) the credential_configurations_supported issuer metadata, (2) RAR objects, (3) credential requests, and (4) batch credential requests. Due to the lack of consistency and identifiability among them, the specification may not fully achieve its intended goal. However, in exchange for sacrificing full interoperability, real-world ecosystems will be able to issue verifiable credential for their specific needs based on the specification along with their supplementary specifications. The specification does not go into the specifics of verifiable credential formats, but it does establish rules related to the jwt_vc_json, jwt_vc_json-ld, ldp_vc, mso_mdoc, and vc+sd-jwt formats. Among them, the formats that have recently been garnering the most attention are “SD-JWT VC” and “mdoc” (ISO/IEC 18013-5:2021). eIDAS 2.0 mandates support for SD-JWT-based and mdoc-based formats. Public key distribution is also not covered in the specification. Some recognized proposals for public key distribution include (1) embedding an X.509 certificate in the verifiable credential itself, (2) using "openid_credential_issuer"."jwks" in the entity configuration of the credential issuer, and (3) using /.well-known/jwt-vc-issuer. While the OID4VCI specification still has room for improvements, real-world ecosystems can leverage it for their specific needs with practical compromises and local supplementary specifications.

3. OID4VCI Implementation

3.1. Authlete Overview

Developers can build their own credential issuers and authorization servers / OpenID providers conforming to the OID4VCI specification by utilizing Authlete. While most vendors directly provide implementations of frontend servers such as an authorization server, Authlete takes a different approach. Authlete provides a set of Web APIs with which developers themselves can implement their own frontend servers. Authlete sits behind such frontend servers and is invisible from end users.

The Authlete architecture inevitably requires developers to build frontend servers, but in return, developers receive the following benefits.

Any technical components of developer’s choice
- User authentication method
- User management system
- API gateway
- Programming language
- Web framework
- Cloud service
Full control over user data
- No need to upload user data to the OAuth/OIDC vendor’s server.
- Manageable compliance with various regulations for the protection of user data.
Full control over end-user facing frontend servers
- Corporate brand management across all aspects of UI/UX.
Enforced proper layer separation in system design
- API authorization is separated from user management and user authentication.
- OAuth/OIDC protocol processing is separated from API gateway and frontend servers.

Architects in enterprises have begun to realize that they need full control over user identity management and the Web APIs of their services for the success of their business and recognize that the “OAuth/OIDC component as a Service” approach offered by Authlete is the ideal solution. Please watch “Security Offered as Components Empowering Enterprises to Gain Control”, a panel discussion on this topic held at EIC 2023.

3.2. Authlete Configuration

3.2.1. Authlete Version

The OID4VCI specification is supported from Authlete 3.0, which is scheduled to be released around April 2024. Until then, a trial server is available for customers and business partners. If you are interested in trying OID4VCI, please contact us.

3.2.2. Authlete Server Configuration

The “Verifiable Credentials” feature must be enabled on the Authlete server. If you are using the on-premises version of Authlete, please confirm that the configuration file (authlete-server.properties) includes the following line to enable this feature.

feature.verifiable_credentials.enabled=true

3.2.3. Authlete Service Configuration

Property		Type	Description
`verifiableCredentialsEnabled`		boolean	This flag controls availability of features related to Verifiable Credentials such as support of the OID4VCI specification.
`credentialIssuerMetadata`	`credentialIssuer`	string	The identifier of the credential issuer when this service acts as a credential issuer. This property corresponds to the `credential_issuer` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The value must be a valid URL with the `https` scheme and without the query part and the fragment part. In addition, Authlete limits the value to ASCII only and a maximum length of 200 characters.To act as a credential issuer, this property must be set.
	`authorizationServers`	string array	The identifiers of the authorization servers the credential issuer relies on for authorization when this service acts as a credential issuer. This property corresponds to the `authorization_servers` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The values must be HTTP-accessible URLs.
	`credentialEndpoint`	string	The URL of the credential endpoint when this service acts as a credential issuer. This property corresponds to the `credential_endpoint` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The value must be a valid URL with the `https` scheme and without the fragment part. In addition, Authlete limits the value to ASCII only and a maximum length of 200 characters.To act as a credential issuer, this property must be set.
	`batchCredentialEndpoint`	string	The URL of the batch credential endpoint when this service acts as a credential issuer. This property corresponds to the `batch_credential_endpoint` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The value must be a valid URL with the `https` scheme and without the fragment part. In addition, Authlete limits the value to ASCII only and a maximum length of 200 characters.It is optional whether to implement the batch credential endpoint.
	`deferredCredentialEndpoint`	string	The URL of the deferred credential endpoint when this service acts as a credential issuer. This property corresponds to the `deferred_credential_endpoint` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The value must be a valid URL with the `https` scheme and without the fragment part. In addition, Authlete limits the value to ASCII only and a maximum length of 200 characters.If the credential endpoint and/or the batch credential endpoint of your credential issuer may issue transaction IDs, you must implement the deferred credential endpoint.
	`credentialResponseEncryptionAlgValuesSupported`	string array	The JWE `alg` algorithms supported for credential response encryption. This property corresponds to the `credential_response_encryption.alg_values_supported` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The valid values are the names of JWEAlg enum entries such as `"ECDH_ES"`. Only asymmetric algorithms are accepted.
	`credentialResponseEncryptionEncValuesSupported`	string array	The JWE `enc` algorithms supported for credential response encryption. This property corresponds to the `credential_response_encryption.enc_values_supported` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The valid values are the names of JWEEnc enum entries such as `"A256GCM"`.
	`requireCredentialEncryptionResponse`	boolean	The flag indicating whether to always encrypt credential responses. This property corresponds to the `credential_response_encryption.encryption_required` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.If this property is set to true, every credential request is required to include the `credential_response_encryption` JSON object.
	`credentialsSupported`	string	Credentials supported by the credential issuer when this service acts as a credential issuer. This property corresponds to the `credential_configurations_supported` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.The value must be a JSON object. Non-ASCII characters may be contained, but Authlete limits the maximum number of characters to 16383.To act as a credential issuer, this property must be set.For backward compatibility, the name of this property remains `credentialsSupported` and will not be renamed to `credentialConfigurationsSupported`.
`credentialOfferDuration`		integer	The default duration of credential offers in seconds.When an API to the `/vci/offer/create` API does not contain the `duration` request parameter or the value of the parameter is 0 or negative, the value of this property is used as the default value.If the value of this property is 0 or negative, the default value per Authlete server is used as the default value.
`preAuthorizedGrantAnonymousAccessSupported`		boolean	This property indicates whether token requests using the pre-authorized code flow by unidentifiable client applications are allowed.This property corresponds to the `pre-authorized_grant_anonymous_access_supported` metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification.
`cnonceDuration`		integer	The duration of `c_nonce` in seconds.When the token endpoint of the authorization server issues an access token usable for verifiable credential issuance, it also issues a `c_nonce` alongside the access token. In addition, the credential endpoint and the batch credential endpoint of the credential issuer issue a new `c_nonce` when the presented `c_nonce` has already expired. This property is used as the lifetime of such `c_nonce`s.If the value of this property is 0 or negative, the default value per Authlete server is used.
`credentialTransactionDuration`		integer	The default duration of transaction IDs in seconds that may be issued as a result of a credential request or a batch credential request.If the value of this property is 0 or negative, the default value per Authlete server is used.
`credentialDuration`		integer	The default duration of verifiable credentials in seconds.Some Authlete APIs such as the `/vci/single/issue` API and the `/vci/batch/issue` API may issue one or more verifiable credentials. The value of this property specifies the default duration of such verifiable credentials.The value 0 indicates that verifiable credentials will not expire. In the case, verifiable credentials will not have a property that indicates the expiration time. For example, JWT-based verifiable credentials will not contain the `exp` claim (RFC 7519, Section 4.1.4).Authlete APIs that may issue verifiable credentials recognize a request parameter that can override the duration. For example, a request to the `/vci/single/issue` API contains an `order` object that has a `credentialDuration` parameter that can override the default duration.
`credentialJwks`		string	The JWK Set document containing private keys that are used to sign verifiable credentials.Some Authlete APIs such as the `/vci/single/issue` API and the `/vci/batch/issue` API may issue one or more verifiable credentials. The content of this property is referred to by such APIs.Authlete APIs that may issue verifiable credentials recognize a request parameter that can specify the key ID of a private key that should be used for signing. For example, a request to the `/vci/single/issue` API contains an `order` object that has a `signingKeyId` parameter that can specify the key ID of a private key to be used for signing. When a key ID is not specified, Authlete will select a private key automatically.If JWKs in the JWK Set do not contain the `kid` property (RFC 7517, Section 4.5) when this `credentialJwks` property is updated, Authlete will automatically insert the `kid` property into such JWKs. The JWK thumbprint (RFC 7638) computed with the SHA-256 hash algorithm is used as the value of the `kid` property.
`credentialJwksUri`		string	The URL at which the JWK Set document of the credential issuer is exposed.This URL is used as the value of the `jwks_uri` property in the JWT issuer metadata. The metadata itself is published at `/.well-known/jwt-issuer`. See SD-JWT-based Verifiable Credentials (SD-JWT VC) for details about the JWT issuer metadata.

3.3. Authlete APIs

3.3.1. Overall Picture of Authlete APIs for OID4VCI

The following diagram illustrates the relationship between the endpoints of the frontend servers (the credential issuer and the authorization server) and Authlete APIs. The details of the Authlete APIs are explained in the following sections.

3.3.2. Authlete API Call

A significant difference between Authlete 2.x and Authlete 3.0 is how to call Authlete APIs. In Authlete 2.x and older versions, developers call Authlete APIs using a pair of an API key and an API secret (e.g., a service API key and a service API secret). In Authlete 3.0, on the other hand, developers call Authlete APIs with an access token. Developers can obtain access tokens for Authlete APIs using the new Web console, which is significantly different from the previous ones. In Authlete 2.x and older versions, there are two separate Web consoles: the service owner console (for managing services corresponding to authorization servers and OpenID providers) and the developer console (for managing client applications). In Authlete 3.0, however, a single Web console is provided, and its appearance and functionality change based to on the privileges of the presented access token.

	Authlete 2.x	Authlete 3.0
Protection	API key & API secret	Access token
Web Console	The service owner console and the developer console	A single console

Another difference is found in the path component of Authlete APIs. In Authlete 3.0, most Authlete APIs include a service ID as part of the path, such as /api/{ServiceID}/auth/authorization, where {ServiceID} represents the identifier of a service (i.e., the service API key in Authlete 2.x).

Authlete Version	API Path Example
Authlete 2.x	`/api/auth/authorization`
Authlete 3.0	`/api/``{ServiceID}``/auth/authorization`

In this document, as well as in other documents, the prefix /api/{ServiceID} for API paths is omitted.

These changes are not insignificant, but their impact on programs can be minimized by absorbing the differences at the library layer. For instance, developers using the sample authorization server written in Java (authlete/java-oauth-server) and switching from Authlete 2.x to Authlete 3.0 only need to modify the content of the configuration file (authlete.properties) from:

# For Authlete 2.x
base_url = ...
service.api_key = ..
service.api_secret = ...

to:

# For Authlete 3.0
api_version = V3
base_url = ...
service.api_key = ...
service.access_token = ...

3.4. Credential Offer Issuance

As mentioned before, the process of issuing credential offers varies among credential issuers. For example, after interacting with a user via a web browser, the credential issuer may display a QR code like below:

that represents “openid-credential-offer://?credential_offer={CredentialOffer}” where {CredentialOffer} holds the following credential offer.

{
  "credential_issuer": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "credential_configuration_ids": [
    "IdentityCredential",
    "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL"
  ],
  "grants": {
    "urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code": {
      "pre-authorized_code": "NH9udMon5pTuuvbsNsHUNWf8tpU__9wt-gsO9LeYthc"
    }
  }
}

The credential issuer may instead show a hyperlink like below:

openid-credential-offer://?credential_offer_uri={CredentialOfferUri}

where {CredentialOfferUri} holds a URL-encoded URL like https%3A%2F%2Ftrial.authlete.net%2Fapi%2Foffer%2FTctoiNm9lYASTBT6XRGb8RQsrClKczCxDtqLY1jLvpk.

3.4.1. The `/vci/offer/create` API

Regardless, credential issuers supporting credential offers must be able to create them. For the functionality, Authlete provides the /vci/offer/create API. The following table summarizes the API.

Request to the /vci/offer/create API
HTTP Method and Content-Type	GET	(query parameters)
	POST	`application/json`
	POST	`application/x-www-form-urlencoded`
Request Parameters	`credentialConfigurationIds`	A string array, which will be used as the value of the `"credential_configuration_ids"` property of a credential offer. This request parameter is mandatory.
	`authorizationCodeGrantIncluded`	A boolean value (`true` or `false`) indicating whether to include the `"authorization_code"` object in the `"grants"` object.
	`issuerStateIncluded`	A boolean value (`true` or `false`) indicating whether to include the `"issuer_state"` property in the `"authorization_code"` object in the `"grants"` object.When this parameter is `true`, Authlete generates an issuer state and puts it in the `"authorization_code"` object as the value of the `"issuer_state"` property.
	`preAuthorizedCodeGrantIncluded`	A boolean value (`true` or `false`) indicating whether to include the `"urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code"` object in the `"grants"` object.When this parameter is `true`, Authlete generates a pre-authorized code and puts it in the `"urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code"` object as the value of the `"pre-authorized_code"` property.
	`txCode`	A transaction code that should be associated with the pre-authorized code. If this parameter is not empty, a `tx_code` object will be embedded in the `"urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code"` object. Consequently, the token request using the pre-authorized code will have to include the `tx_code` request parameter with the value specified by this parameter.
	`txCodeInputMode`	The input mode of the transaction code. The value specified by this parameter will be used as the value of the `input_mode` property in the `tx_code` object.The predefined values listed in the OID4VCI specification are `"numeric"` and `"text"` only, but the `/vci/offer/create` API accepts other values for the future extension in addition to the predefined ones.
	`txCodeDescription`	The description of the transaction code. The value specified by this parameter will be used as the value of the `description` property in the `tx_code` object.
	`subject`	The subject (the unique identifier) of the user associated with the credential offer.This parameter is mandatory.
	`duration`	The duration of the credential offer in seconds.If this parameter holds a positive integer, the value is used as the duration of the credential offer being issued. Otherwise, the value of the `credentialOfferDuration` property of the service is used.
	`context`	The general-purpose arbitrary string associated with the credential offer.Developers can utilize this parameter as they like. Authlete does not care about the content of this parameter.
	`properties`	The extra properties associated with the credential offer, which are general-purpose key-value pairs.The extra properties will be eventually associated with an access token which will be created based on the credential offer.
	`jwtAtClaims`	The additional claims in JSON object format that are added to the payload part of the JWT access token.This parameter has a meaning only when the format of access tokens issued by the service is JWT. In other words, it has a meaning only when the `accessTokenSignAlg` property of the service holds a non-null value.The additional claims will be eventually associated with an access token which will be created based on the credential offer.
	`authTime`	The time when the user authentication was performed during the course of issuing the credential offer.The time is represented as seconds since the Unix epoch.
	`acr`	The Authentication Context Class Reference of the user authentication performed during the course of issuing the credential offer.

For example, the following command lines create a credential offer.

$ BASE_URL=https://nextdev-api.authlete.net
$ SERVICE_ID=986126671
$ ACCESS_TOKEN=YOUR_ACCESS_TOKEN
$ curl -s $BASE_URL/api/$SERVICE_ID/vci/offer/create \
    -H "Authorization: Bearer $ACCESS_TOKEN" \
    -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
    -d '{"credentialConfigurationIds":["IdentityCredential"],"preAuthorizedCodeGrantIncluded":true,"txCode":"123456","txCodeInputMode":"numeric","subject":"1001"}'

The /vci/offer/create API returns JSON like below.

{
  "type": "credentialOfferCreateResponse",
  "resultCode": "A366001",
  "resultMessage": "[A366001] A credential offer was created successfully.",
  "action": "CREATED",
  "info": {
    "authTime": 0,
    "authorizationCodeGrantIncluded": false,
    "credentialConfigurationIds": [
      "IdentityCredential"
    ],
    "credentialIssuer": "https://trial.authlete.net",
    "credentialOffer": "{\"credential_issuer\":\"https://trial.authlete.net\",\"credential_configuration_ids\":[\"IdentityCredential\"],\"grants\":{\"urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code\":{\"pre-authorized_code\":\"rS8D7asTTL8MaXM5yLjQvaAMmPmierRW6oeK-4JP4Uk\",\"tx_code\":{\"length\":6,\"input_mode\":\"numeric\"}}}}",
    "expiresAt": 1703929674224,
    "identifier": "9gjVvas8Q5BkkrkSfZv-DbsBYJvlw6ZPMK-TeCkQDEc",
    "issuerStateIncluded": false,
    "preAuthorizedCode": "rS8D7asTTL8MaXM5yLjQvaAMmPmierRW6oeK-4JP4Uk",
    "preAuthorizedCodeGrantIncluded": true,
    "subject": "1001",
    "txCode": "123456",
    "txCodeInputMode": "numeric"
  }
}

The "info" object in the API response contains information about the created credential offer. The "credentialOffer" property in the "info" object is a string representing the created credential offer. The value of the "credentialOffer" property in the above example looks like the following when formatted in a human-readable manner.

{
  "credential_issuer": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "credential_configuration_ids": [
    "IdentityCredential"
  ],
  "grants": {
    "urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code": {
      "pre-authorized_code": "rS8D7asTTL8MaXM5yLjQvaAMmPmierRW6oeK-4JP4Uk",
      "tx_code": {
        "length": 6,
        "input_mode": "numeric"
      }
    }
  }
}

With the value of the "credentialOffer" property, you can construct a URL by concatenating the following components:

A credential offer endpoint. For example, openid-credential-offer://.
?credential_offer=.
URL-encoded "credentialOffer" value.

openid-credential-offer://?credential_offer=%7B%22credential_issuer%22%3A%22https%3A%2F%2Ftrial.authlete.net%22%2C%22credential_configuration_ids%22%3A%5B%22IdentityCredential%22%5D%2C%22grants%22%3A%7B%22urn%3Aietf%3Aparams%3Aoauth%3Agrant-type%3Apre-authorized_code%22%3A%7B%22pre-authorized_code%22%3A%22rS8D7asTTL8MaXM5yLjQvaAMmPmierRW6oeK-4JP4Uk%22%2C%22tx_code%22%3A%7B%22length%22%3A6%2C%22input_mode%22%3A%22numeric%22%7D%7D%7D%7D

The request to and the response from the /vci/offer/create API are represented by the CredentialOfferCreateRequest and CredentialOfferCreateResponse Java classes in the authlete-java-common library, respectively. Please refer to the library’s JavaDoc for details.

3.4.2. The `/vci/offer/info` API

The /vci/offer/info API returns information about a credential offer. This API accepts the identifier request parameter that specifies the identifier of a credential offer.

Request to the /vci/offer/info API
HTTP Method and Content-Type	GET	(path parameters)
	POST	`application/json`
	POST	`application/x-www-form-urlencoded`
Request Parameters	`identifier`	The identifier of a credential offer. When the API call is an HTTP GET request, the identifier is specified as the last path component like `/vci/offer/info/{identifier}`.

The identifier is included in the response from the /vci/offer/create API. The value of the "identifier" property in the "info" object is the identifier. In the example in the previous section, its value is 9gjVvas8Q5BkkrkSfZv-DbsBYJvlw6ZPMK-TeCkQDEc. The following command lines query information about the credential offer created in the previous section.

$ CREDENTIAL_OFFER_IDENTIFIER=9gjVvas8Q5BkkrkSfZv-DbsBYJvlw6ZPMK-TeCkQDEc
$ curl -s ${BASE_URL}/api/${SERVICE_ID}/vci/offer/info/${CREDENTIAL_OFFER_IDENTIFIER} \
    -H "Authorization: Bearer ${ACCESS_TOKEN}"

The /vci/offer/info API returns JSON like below, which is almost the same as the response from the /vci/offer/create API.

{
  "type": "credentialOfferInfoResponse",
  "resultCode": "A368001",
  "resultMessage": "[A368001] Information about the credential offer was obtained successfully.",
  "action": "OK",
  "info": {
    "authTime": 0,
    "authorizationCodeGrantIncluded": false,
    "credentialConfigurationIds": [
      "IdentityCredential"
    ],
    "credentialIssuer": "https://trial.authlete.net",
    "credentialOffer": "{\"credential_issuer\":\"https://trial.authlete.net\",\"credential_configuration_ids\":[\"IdentityCredential\"],\"grants\":{\"urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code\":{\"pre-authorized_code\":\"rS8D7asTTL8MaXM5yLjQvaAMmPmierRW6oeK-4JP4Uk\",\"tx_code\":{\"length\":6,\"input_mode\":\"numeric\"}}}}",
    "expiresAt": 1703929674000,
    "identifier": "9gjVvas8Q5BkkrkSfZv-DbsBYJvlw6ZPMK-TeCkQDEc",
    "issuerStateIncluded": false,
    "preAuthorizedCode": "rS8D7asTTL8MaXM5yLjQvaAMmPmierRW6oeK-4JP4Uk",
    "preAuthorizedCodeGrantIncluded": true,
    "subject": "1001",
    "txCode": "123456",
    "txCodeInputMode": "numeric"
  }
}

The main purpose of the /vci/offer/info API is to assist developers in implementing an endpoint on their credential issuer that provides information about a credential offer when queried by a wallet.

If such endpoint is available, you can construct a URL by concatenating the following components:

A credential offer endpoint. For example, openid-credential-offer://.
?credential_offer_uri=.
URL-encoded URL of the endpoint including the identifier of the credential offer. For example, https://trial.authlete.net/api/offer/9gjVvas8Q5BkkrkSfZv-DbsBYJvlw6ZPMK-TeCkQDEc.

openid-credential-offer://?credential_offer_uri=https%3A%2F%2Ftrial.authlete.net%2Fapi%2Foffer%2F9gjVvas8Q5BkkrkSfZv-DbsBYJvlw6ZPMK-TeCkQDEc

3.4.3. Credential Offer Issuance Example

The sample authorization server implementation written in Java, authlete/java-oauth-server, can function as a credential issuer. Its /api/offer/issue endpoint provides an HTML page for developers to create custom credential offers. A java-oauth-server instance using Authlete 3.0 is currently running at https://trial.authlete.net, and the endpoint is active for trial purposes at https://trial.authlete.net/api/offer/issue.

The HTML page requires user authentication. The test accounts embedded in java-oauth-server can be used. However, if you want to issue an mdoc-based VC, please use inga.

Subject	Login ID	Password
1001	`john`	`john`
1002	`jane`	`jane`
1003	`max`	`max`
1004	`inga`	`inga`

3.5. Credential Endpoint Implementation

The credential endpoint can be implemented using the following Authlete APIs.

	Authlete API	Description
1	`/auth/introspection`	validates the presented access token, and returns the information about the access token.
2	`/vci/single/parse`	parses and validates the received credential request, and returns the information about the credential request.
3	`/vci/single/issue`	issues a verifiable credential or a transaction ID, and prepares the credential response.

Let’s go through the processing steps within a credential endpoint implementation. As the first step, the implementation of the credential endpoint receives a credential request from a wallet.

The implementation extracts the access token from the credential request and passes it to Authlete’s /auth/introspection API.

The /auth/introspection API validates the access token, and returns information about the access token.

If the access token is valid, the endpoint implementation sends the access token and the message body of the credential request to the /vci/single/parse API.

You might wonder why the access token is sent to the /vci/single/parse API, even though its validation has already been completed. The reason for this is that, in Authlete’s implementation, c_nonce is associated with an access token. To validate the nonce claim in a key proof that may be included in the credential request, Authlete needs to know the value of c_nonce associated with the access token.

The /vci/single/parse API parses and validates the credential request, and returns the information about the credential request.

The endpoint implementation prepares a “credential issuance order”, which contains necessary information for Authlete to issue a verifiable credential. The details about this preparation will be discussed later.

The endpoint implementation sends the credential issuance order and the access token to the /vci/single/issue API.

The reason for sending the access token to Authlete again is the need to refresh the c_nonce value associated with the access token in case it has expired.

The /vci/single/issue API issues a verifiable credential or a transaction ID according to the credential issuance order, and prepares the content of the credential response.

The endpoint implementation builds an HTTP response that represents the credential response from the endpoint to the wallet. The response content prepared by the /vci/single/issue API can be used as the message body of the credential response.

Finally, the credential endpoint returns the credential response to the wallet.

The following diagram illustrates the processing steps within a credential endpoint implementation.

3.5.1. Credential Issuance Order

The steps to prepare a credential issuance order are as follows.

3.5.1.1. Credential Issuance Order Step 1

Get the subject (= unique identifier) of the user associated with the access token from the access token information. The "subject" property in the response from the /auth/introspection API (cf. IntrospectionResponse) holds the value of the subject.

3.5.1.2. Credential Issuance Order Step 2

Retrieve information about the user identified by the subject from the user database.

3.5.1.3. Credential Issuance Order Step 3

Get the information about the issuable credentials associated with the access token from the access token information. The "issuableCredentials" property in the response from the /auth/introspection API holds the information as a string. This string needs to be parsed as a JSON array.

3.5.1.4. Credential Issuance Order Step 4

Get the credential information included in the credential request from the credential request information. The "info" object in the response from the /vci/single/parse API (cf. CredentialSingleParseResponse) holds various information about the credential request. The combination of the "format" property and the "details" property in the "info" object represent the credential information.

The value of the "details" property is a string. The string needs to be parsed as a JSON object. The content of the JSON object is almost the same as the credential request except that it does not contain the "format" parameter, the "proof" parameter, and the "credential_response_encryption" parameter.

3.5.1.5. Credential Issuance Order Step 5

Confirm that the access token has the necessary permissions for the credential request by checking if the credential information is a subset of any issuable credentials.

However, if you are a programmer, you can understand that the current OID4VCI specification makes it challenging to implement this step. Furthermore, in the case of SD-JWT VC, there is a proposal to make vct determine the set of claims and eliminate the need to specify individual claims one by one. The proposal makes it impossible to check the access token’s permissions only by mechanically seeing the inclusion relationship between JSON objects. Therefore, the confirmation of whether the access token has sufficient permissions is left to be implemented by each credential issuer according to their respective policies. While permission checks based on inclusion relationships are implemented in Authlete, they have been disabled.

3.5.1.6. Credential Issuance Order Step 6

Determine the set of user claims to embed in the VC being issued based on the credential information, and get the values of the user claims from the dataset retrieved from the user database.

3.5.1.7. Credential Issuance Order Step 7

Build a credential issuance order using the collected data.

A credential issuance order is a JSON object that has the properties listed in the following table.

Property	Type	Description
`requestIdentifier`	string	The identifier of the credential request which has been assigned by Authlete. The `info.identifier` property in the response from the `/vci/single/parse` API is the identifier. This property is mandatory.
`credentialPayload`	string	The additional payload added to the VC being issued. The format of this string must be a JSON object. The set of the user claims should be converted into JSON and set to this property. This parameter is optional.
`issuanceDeferred`	boolean	The flag indicating whether to defer the credential issuance. When this property is `true`, the `/vci/single/issue` API issues a transaction ID instead of a VC.
`credentialDuration`	integer	The duration of the VC in seconds. If the value of this property is a positive number, the value is used as the duration. If the value is 0, the default duration of the service is used. If the value is a negative number, the VC will not have an expiration time.
`signingKeyId`	string	The key ID of the private key that should be used for signing the VC being issued. If omitted, Authlete will select a key automatically.

3.5.1.8. Credential Issuance Order Step 8

Prepare a request to the /vci/single/issue API (cf. CredentialSingleIssueRequest).

Request to the /vci/single/issue API
HTTP Method and Content-Type	POST	`application/json`
Request Parameters	`accessToken`	The access token presented at the credential endpoint.
Request Parameters	`order`	A credential issuance order that provides an instruction for issuing a verifiable credential or a transaction ID.

3.5.1.9. Credential Issuance Order Step 9

Send the prepared request to the /vci/single/issue API.

3.5.1.10. Credential Issuance Order Steps Summary

The following diagram is a summary of the steps for preparing a credential issuance order.

3.6. Batch Credential Endpoint Implementation

To be written.

3.7. Configure `oid4vci` in the Authlete Management Console

As mentioned in 3.3.2. Authlete API Call, Authlete 3 has a single console to configure services and clients. You can configure the Verifiable Credentials such as support of the OID4VCI specification in the Authlete Management Console.

3.7.1. Service Settings

To enable oid4vci in Authlete Service Settings:

Log in to the Authlete Management Console
Click on your Organization name and choose your Service.
Navigate to Service Settings > Verifiable Credentials > General
Under the Verifiable Credentials Feature section, press Enable to turn on support for Verifiable Credentials.
Optionally, enable the Anonymous Access property if you want to allow token requests by unidentifiable client applications.
Click the Save Changes button to apply the updates.

To configure oid4vci Credential Issuer Metadata Properties:

Navigate to Service Settings > Verifiable Credentials > Credential Issuer Metadata
Configure the metadata properties to suit your requirements. The following properties correspond to the metadata defined in the OID4VCI specification:
- Authorization Servers
- Credential Issuer Identifier
- Credential Endpoint
- Batch Credential Endpoint
- Deferred Credential Endpoint
- Supported Credentials
- Anonymous Access
Click the Save Changes button to apply the updates.

3.7.2. Client Settings

To configure oid4vci in Authlete Client Settings:

Log in to the Authlete Management Console
Click on your Organization name and choose your Service.
Navigate to Client Settings > Verifiable Credentials > General
Under the Credential Response Encryption section, enable Require option to turn on support for response encryption.
Click the Save Changes button to apply the updates.

4. OID4VCI Demo

4.1. Pre-Authorized Code Flow + Key Proof + SD-JWT VC

4.1.1. Setup

Download the resources used in this demo.

git clone git@github.com:authlete/oid4vci-demo.git
cd oid4vci-demo

Set up some shell variables for this demo.

CLIENT_ID=218232426
TOKEN_ENDPOINT=https://trial.authlete.net/api/token
CREDENTIAL_ISSUER=https://trial.authlete.net
CREDENTIAL_ENDPOINT=https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential

4.1.2. Pre-Authorized Code

Access https://trial.authlete.net/api/offer/issue to generate a “credential offer” that contains a “pre-authorized code”.

The page displayed at the URL provides a form to create an arbitrary credential offer for demo purposes. If “Pre-authorized code grant included” in the form is checked, a pre-authorized code will be included in the credential offer being issued. Input inga and inga in the “Login ID” field and the “Password” field, confirm that “Pre-authorized code grant included” is checked, and press the “Submit” button. You will see a result page displayed.

The result page will show a QR code which represents a URL including a credential offer. The content of the credential offer is shown in the JSON placed under the QR code. The value of the pre-authorized_code property in the JSON is the issued pre-authorized code. Set the issued pre-authorized code to shell variable PRE_AUTHORIZED_CODE to use it in the next step.

PRE_AUTHORIZED_CODE=NH9udMon5pTuuvbsNsHUNWf8tpU__9wt-gsO9LeYthc

4.1.3. Access Token

Send a token request using the pre-authorized code flow. The client for this demo is a public client, so client authentication is not required. That is, it’s not necessary to add request parameters related to client authentication.

curl -s $TOKEN_ENDPOINT \
     -d client_id=$CLIENT_ID \
     -d grant_type=urn:ietf:params:oauth:grant-type:pre-authorized_code \
     -d pre-authorized_code=$PRE_AUTHORIZED_CODE

The token endpoint will return a response like below.

{
  "access_token": "xj2YRmSV-_e15n7mTXSvkCH-Yw-XklRagEHF5WXE7R4",
  "token_type": "Bearer",
  "expires_in": 86400,
  "scope": null,
  "refresh_token": "Oq7H2GsuES4Z6d_63Dn7rWhJ9rCpgzmzwQ-BYtGR1yE",
  "c_nonce": "EhTC8LA6kVrrO6_XiC7N6N_wXdma2Zs1LHAQBZ5E0T0",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

The response will contain the access_token parameter and the c_nonce parameter. Set the values of the response parameters to shell variables for later use.

ACCESS_TOKEN=xj2YRmSV-_e15n7mTXSvkCH-Yw-XklRagEHF5WXE7R4
C_NONCE=EhTC8LA6kVrrO6_XiC7N6N_wXdma2Zs1LHAQBZ5E0T0

4.1.4. Key Proof

Generate a “key proof JWT” using the holder key holder.jwk and the generate-key-proof script. The JWK file and the script are contained in the oid4vci-demo repository.

./generate-key-proof \
    -i $CREDENTIAL_ISSUER \
    -k holder.jwk \
    -c $CLIENT_ID \
    -n $C_NONCE

The generate-key-proof script will generate a key proof JWT like below.

eyJ0eXAiOiJvcGVuaWQ0dmNpLXByb29mK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiUFN4UXJEMnpsMF9tWGNBcXoxbWdxU2VCb0Jobm14Mnl4QkVwckJZOEYyMCIsInkiOiJ4VjhmYmkxRlNvc1V1bkxldUxOdUxrSmlxbVk2VEtpTW51ci1HbjJ3UjEwIn19.eyJpc3MiOiIyMTgyMzI0MjYiLCJhdWQiOiJodHRwczovL3RyaWFsLmF1dGhsZXRlLm5ldCIsImlhdCI6MTcwMzg0NzM3Niwibm9uY2UiOiJFaFRDOExBNmtWcnJPNl9YaUM3TjZOX3dYZG1hMlpzMUxIQVFCWjVFMFQwIn0.6l8QnPTclDUoWH5PsVsZQDauA_HcIVDGxU9-TfezflIIAzTFgeC5nTr5rLBkEIgcfUvkUOwKqlM06LdVVwTZlw

Decoding the header and the payload of the key proof JWT by base64url will show the following JSONs.

{
  "typ": "openid4vci-proof+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "PSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20",
    "y": "xV8fbi1FSosUunLeuLNuLkJiqmY6TKiMnur-Gn2wR10"
  }
}

{
  "iss": "218232426",
  "aud": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "iat": 1703847376,
  "nonce": "EhTC8LA6kVrrO6_XiC7N6N_wXdma2Zs1LHAQBZ5E0T0"
}

The result of executing the generate-key-proof script can be directly set to the shell variable KEY_PROOF_JWT by doing the following.

KEY_PROOF_JWT=`./generate-key-proof -i $CREDENTIAL_ISSUER -k holder.jwk -c $CLIENT_ID -n $C_NONCE`

4.1.5. SD-JWT VC

Send a “credential request” with the generated key proof JWT to the “credential endpoint”.

curl -s $CREDENTIAL_ENDPOINT \
       -H "Authorization: Bearer $ACCESS_TOKEN" \
       -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
       --data '{
  "format": "vc+sd-jwt",
  "vct": "https://credentials.example.com/identity_credential",
  "proof": {
    "proof_type": "jwt",
    "jwt":"'${KEY_PROOF_JWT}'"
  }
}'

The credential endpoint will return a response like below.

{
  "credential": "eyJraWQiOiJKMUZ3SlA4N0M2LVFOX1dTSU9tSkFRYzZuNUNRX2JaZGFGSjVHRG5XMVJrIiwidHlwIjoidmMrc2Qtand0IiwiYWxnIjoiRVMyNTYifQ.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.2k4JTf61BOs461fLToA9VwZbY64i9TIfchZVasC0OCx2rDJYodeRc6uVjYuHBOZUHlMJ1WdTjCFfKuxE5juxMA~WyIxMjBTWFZhTzZKTWxoc0dIZUdVdktRIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd~WyJVUl9MTU5ocGFLUUVpbEQ1TXc5RnB3IiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ~WyJhT2huYjgySmFMbjZ0OHRZZXpGanl3IiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd~WyJGNzE0ZktfRFpSMm83ajFWRkpIUW5BIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd~",
  "c_nonce": "EhTC8LA6kVrrO6_XiC7N6N_wXdma2Zs1LHAQBZ5E0T0",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 85956
}

The value of the credential parameter in the response is the issued SD-JWT VC. If the SD-JWT VC is set to the shell variable SD_JWT, the content of the SD-JWT VC can be decoded by invoking the decode-sd-jwt script as follows.

./decode-sd-jwt $SD_JWT

The result will look like below.

{
  "kid": "J1FwJP87C6-QN_WSIOmJAQc6n5CQ_bZdaFJ5GDnW1Rk",
  "typ": "vc+sd-jwt",
  "alg": "ES256"
}
{
  "_sd": [
    "0DE1pcPz7-DmbW96TKhYGPYD6-9vsmS1kkmDYT86qu4",
    "7WxsSz8WIkAhwKfd4iEWDPk9Hn0WjgUz7JG_xjzEpN4",
    "BUWNBXvnBpgVViJZ-WOMaqdxb94_IDu8HMhFgR56iww",
    "GPjHme8XZKboXXK2YOSf8pMtAssHiJANPuouZB5A6n4",
    "Ia7qjuSCJgFX4b_OnKjxublSKSZdVqHEtJUDvGEkDYQ",
    "Pzu-PEjRQ9l_o6EDRjtBpiifjQSLWDMga13elq6iEn8",
    "U4PXwJ03-zyDyKidYOAk1RC35cYOaBvvyloABs7mvuE",
    "lkOPBNoj4Y48a8kQxViSJBeAgbxNXLGRhB9vIbz2Bv8",
    "nP7Lri6BijTqtUR6q4_jL1O9rZwv8OltiD_YTXiSkfk",
    "t_VmlPBlMpCbDnMR8saGC_fj1VBoqB-U2fMMafMmTMk"
  ],
  "vct": "https://credentials.example.com/identity_credential",
  "_sd_alg": "sha-256",
  "iss": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "cnf": {
    "jwk": {
      "kty": "EC",
      "crv": "P-256",
      "kid": "4M9kIrB9WYzt1GQgL12lzdBZsGyeV3lgPKov28oT5L4",
      "x": "PSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20",
      "y": "xV8fbi1FSosUunLeuLNuLkJiqmY6TKiMnur-Gn2wR10"
    }
  },
  "iat": 1703847605
}
{
  "digest": "lkOPBNoj4Y48a8kQxViSJBeAgbxNXLGRhB9vIbz2Bv8",
  "WyIxMjBTWFZhTzZKTWxoc0dIZUdVdktRIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd": [
    "120SXVaO6JMlhsGHeGUvKQ",
    "sub",
    "1004"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "0DE1pcPz7-DmbW96TKhYGPYD6-9vsmS1kkmDYT86qu4",
  "WyJVUl9MTU5ocGFLUUVpbEQ1TXc5RnB3IiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ": [
    "UR_LMNhpaKQEilD5Mw9Fpw",
    "given_name",
    "Inga"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "nP7Lri6BijTqtUR6q4_jL1O9rZwv8OltiD_YTXiSkfk",
  "WyJhT2huYjgySmFMbjZ0OHRZZXpGanl3IiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd": [
    "aOhnb82JaLn6t8tYezFjyw",
    "family_name",
    "Silverstone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "U4PXwJ03-zyDyKidYOAk1RC35cYOaBvvyloABs7mvuE",
  "WyJGNzE0ZktfRFpSMm83ajFWRkpIUW5BIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd": [
    "F714fK_DZR2o7j1VFJHQnA",
    "birthdate",
    "1991-11-06"
  ]
}

4.2. Authorization Code Flow + PAR + DPoP + mdoc

4.2.1. Setup

Download the resources used in this demo.

git clone git@github.com:authlete/oid4vci-demo.git
cd oid4vci-demo

Set up some shell variables for this demo.

CLIENT_ID=218232426
TOKEN_ENDPOINT=https://trial.authlete.net/api/token
CREDENTIAL_ISSUER=https://trial.authlete.net
CREDENTIAL_ENDPOINT=https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential
PAR_ENDPOINT=https://trial.authlete.net/api/par

4.2.2. Request URI

Generate a “DPoP proof JWT” (RFC 9449) using dpop.jwk, a private key for DPoP, and the generate-dpop-proof script.

DPOP_PROOF_JWT=`./generate-dpop-proof -k dpop.jwk -m POST -u $PAR_ENDPOINT`

The generate-dpop-proof script will generate a DPoP proof JWT like below.

eyJ0eXAiOiJkcG9wK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiaEdmcXpHWGdhbzFRZ1ZJVFk2a2lIWU9LYmFMWEJ4VHFQSmE0RU9pbXhoSSIsInkiOiJFMUtpQV9mQTJ4OElycnlzb0dkbkJUTUI1LW8zRUpUX01nUUFfSG1HdTlNIn19.eyJqdGkiOiJoRm9HQkFBN3ZXTHExbWJ6IiwiaHRtIjoiUE9TVCIsImh0dSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vdHJpYWwuYXV0aGxldGUubmV0L2FwaS9wYXIiLCJpYXQiOjE3MDM4NjQ5ODR9.9VZtrwjASCEeO6v0SuGqEttYtoHORtGMNn95mSx4uNv04oA8hSDDBo4CoPQiaGsEjunJ_d_zKR7VsrF9M8BBZA

Decoding the header and the payload of the DPoP proof JWT by base64url will show the following JSONs. Note that the htu claim in the payload holds the URL of the PAR endpoint.

{
  "typ": "dpop+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "hGfqzGXgao1QgVITY6kiHYOKbaLXBxTqPJa4EOimxhI",
    "y": "E1KiA_fA2x8IrrysoGdnBTMB5-o3EJT_MgQA_HmGu9M"
  }
}

{
  "jti": "hFoGBAA7vWLq1mbz",
  "htm": "POST",
  "htu": "https://trial.authlete.net/api/par",
  "iat": 1703864984
}

Send a PAR request to the PAR endpoint. The points here are (1) that the PAR request contains the DPoP header and (2) that the scope parameter contains org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL.

curl -s $PAR_ENDPOINT \
     -H "DPoP: $DPOP_PROOF_JWT" \
     -d client_id=$CLIENT_ID \
     -d response_type=code \
     -d scope=org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL

This scope value assumes that the credential_configurations_supported JSON object in the credential issuer metadata contains at least one credential configuration whose scope property holds org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL.

{
  "credential_configurations_supported": {
    "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL": {
      "format": "mso_mdoc",
      "doctype": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
      "scope": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
      "claims": {
        "org.iso.18013.5.1": {
          "family_name": {},
          ...
        }
      }
    }
  },
  ...
}

The PAR endpoint will return a response like below. The value of the request_uri parameter in the response is the issued request URI. It will be used in the next step.

{
  "expires_in": 600,
  "request_uri": "urn:ietf:params:oauth:request_uri:du-ptCtuukbVDi2MgOjYwwb99cl-ho0bzzLb0X0u1n0"
}

4.2.3. Authorization Code

Send an authorization request to the authorization endpoint using a web browser. Don’t forget to replace $REQUEST_URI in the URL with the actual request URI you received from the PAR endpoint in the previous step.

https://trial.authlete.net/api/authorization?client_id=218232426&request_uri=$REQUEST_URI

The authorization page will be displayed. Input inga and inga in the “Login ID” field and the “Password” field there, and press the “Authorize” button.

You will be redirected to the redirection endpoint. The page displayed at this endpoint will show you the value of the issued authorization code. It will be used in the next step.

4.2.4. Access Token

Generate a DPoP proof JWT to access the token endpoint. Make sure that the argument given to the -u option of the generate-dpop-proof script is $TOKEN_ENDPOINT (not $PAR_ENDPOINT).

DPOP_PROOF_JWT=`./generate-dpop-proof -k dpop.jwk -m POST -u $TOKEN_ENDPOINT`

Decoding the header and the payload of the DPoP proof JWT by base64url will show the following JSONs. The htu claim in the payload should hold the URL of the token endpoint.

{
  "typ": "dpop+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "hGfqzGXgao1QgVITY6kiHYOKbaLXBxTqPJa4EOimxhI",
    "y": "E1KiA_fA2x8IrrysoGdnBTMB5-o3EJT_MgQA_HmGu9M"
  }
}

{
  "jti": "KHV6KaCjtqwfnb8r",
  "htm": "POST",
  "htu": "https://trial.authlete.net/api/token",
  "iat": 1703865524
}

Send a token request using the authorization code flow to the token endpoint. Don’t forget to set the authorization code issued in the previous step to the shell variable AUTHORIZATION_CODE before executing the following command.

AUTHORIZATION_CODE=QaPvTUqX-aPDnrcFoCcYDZHW66RzC_vfi6EDq7derNs

curl -s $TOKEN_ENDPOINT \
     -H "DPoP: $DPOP_PROOF_JWT" \
     -d client_id=$CLIENT_ID \
     -d grant_type=authorization_code \
     -d code=$AUTHORIZATION_CODE

The token endpoint will return a response like below.

{
  "access_token": "T01u7-43MOA17hB8DqW-dEaBqUpStWtitYoVW1ewlH4",
  "token_type": "DPoP",
  "expires_in": 86400,
  "scope": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
  "refresh_token": "17on7yghEeGPbaXmjTEMgEGPG8S79DweIBtCq0MZOHE",
  "c_nonce": "LQwqEX7sT1uJkzzTdULvLsHcUvXfUaT79bkzLWEi7jw",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

The response will contain the access_token parameter. Please set the value of the parameter to the shell variable ACCESS_TOKEN for the next step.

ACCESS_TOKEN=T01u7-43MOA17hB8DqW-dEaBqUpStWtitYoVW1ewlH4

4.2.5. mdoc

Generate a DPoP proof JWT to access the credential endpoint. Make sure that (1) the argument given to the -u option of the generate-dpop-proof script is $CREDENTIAL_ENDPOINT and (2) the -a option must be given to embed the ath claim in the DPoP proof JWT.

DPOP_PROOF_JWT=`./generate-dpop-proof -k dpop.jwk -m POST -u $CREDENTIAL_ENDPOINT -a $ACCESS_TOKEN`

Decoding the header and the payload of the DPoP proof JWT by base64url will show the following JSONs. The payload contains the ath claim.

{
  "typ": "dpop+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "hGfqzGXgao1QgVITY6kiHYOKbaLXBxTqPJa4EOimxhI",
    "y": "E1KiA_fA2x8IrrysoGdnBTMB5-o3EJT_MgQA_HmGu9M"
  }
}

{
  "jti": "caK7sLDiAF9HbOi2",
  "htm": "POST",
  "htu": "https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential",
  "iat": 1703865668,
  "ath": "DUuszLa1NHTMoREsPQE0gB9znn1BRKYPUpOwBpVcLJo"
}

Send a “credential request” with the DPoP proof JWT and the access token to the “credential endpoint”.

curl -s $CREDENTIAL_ENDPOINT \
     -H "DPoP: $DPOP_PROOF_JWT" \
     -H "Authorization: DPoP $ACCESS_TOKEN" \
     -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
     --data '{
  "format": "mso_mdoc",
  "doctype": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
  "claims": {
    "org.iso.18013.5.1": {
      "family_name": {},
      "given_name": {},
      "birth_date": {},
      "issue_date": {},
      "expiry_date": {},
      "issuing_country": {},
      "document_number": {},
      "driving_privileges": {}
    }
  }
}'

The credential endpoint will return a response like below.

{
  "credential": "omdkb2NUeXBldW9yZy5pc28uMTgwMTMuNS4xLm1ETGxpc3N1ZXJTaWduZWSiam5hbWVTcGFjZXOhcW9yZy5pc28uMTgwMTMuNS4xiNgYWFukaGRpZ2VzdElEAWZyYW5kb21QJ6e6efO1W1kaYmdXHjpSY3FlbGVtZW50SWRlbnRpZmllcmppc3N1ZV9kYXRlbGVsZW1lbnRWYWx1ZdkD7GoyMDIzLTEyLTI52BhYXKRoZGlnZXN0SUQCZnJhbmRvbVBlLj1uVWnDyBHmzifHfxjhcWVsZW1lbnRJZGVudGlmaWVya2V4cGlyeV9kYXRlbGVsZW1lbnRWYWx1ZdkD7GoyMDI0LTEyLTI52BhYWqRoZGlnZXN0SUQDZnJhbmRvbVAMR8e_GTnz4n7RFXKXgrAQcWVsZW1lbnRJZGVudGlmaWVya2ZhbWlseV9uYW1lbGVsZW1lbnRWYWx1ZWtTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZdgYWFKkaGRpZ2VzdElEBGZyYW5kb21QCHsjtktJ-PkSnEpzHOOCnHFlbGVtZW50SWRlbnRpZmllcmpnaXZlbl9uYW1lbGVsZW1lbnRWYWx1ZWRJbmdh2BhYW6RoZGlnZXN0SUQFZnJhbmRvbVAj-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-xqMjA0My0wMS0wMWppc3N1ZXJBdXRohEOhASahGCFZAWEwggFdMIIBBKADAgECAgYBjJHZwhkwCgYIKoZIzj0EAwIwNjE0MDIGA1UEAwwrSjFGd0pQODdDNi1RTl9XU0lPbUpBUWM2bjVDUV9iWmRhRko1R0RuVzFSazAeFw0yMzEyMjIxNDA2NTZaFw0yNDEwMTcxNDA2NTZaMDYxNDAyBgNVBAMMK0oxRndKUDg3QzYtUU5fV1NJT21KQVFjNm41Q1FfYlpkYUZKNUdEblcxUmswWTATBgcqhkjOPQIBBggqhkjOPQMBBwNCAAQCilV5ugmlhHJzDVgqSRE5d8KkoQqX1jVg8WE4aPjFODZQ66fFPFIhWRP3ioVUi67WGQSgTY3F6Vmjf7JMVQ4MMAoGCCqGSM49BAMCA0cAMEQCIGcWNJwFy8RGV4uMwK7k1vEkqQ2xr-BCGRdN8OZur5PeAiBVrNuxV1C9mCW5z2clhDFaXNdP2Lp_7CBQrHQoJhuPcNgYWQHopWd2ZXJzaW9uYzEuMG9kaWdlc3RBbGdvcml0aG1nU0hBLTI1Nmx2YWx1ZURpZ2VzdHOhcW9yZy5pc28uMTgwMTMuNS4xqAFYIKroraryzIKijf6A0qMLKKEXhO4JkfgeofLS35R-tV-CAlggA1kTuTcqhUUzLu689TY7XaXTKDTQTy-X0CTtJbOgqJsDWCA9I2CynkOK1sgi3P7ZmCZJENPGQl8QsWImdXSNXsqEEARYIJ7fk0E18dWrB3R_X0NGXdshFSplLC2WiMGrqotXnbOVBVggs4p4mEragqpfssdgOpeGrmxeBq8kDp7rpVf-8mngGV4GWCAAGjwiUCuOj0CnVGknOCa217wUJthsqNS8CoxZ5BWQEQdYIDwygoPCSFXyutize7ktwCSKY5T7V4mWpizCFoVSkBy7CFggTWvL8cD_12lYMvje8i2T6YLEwNJNfje5lG6jfeS5I31nZG9jVHlwZXVvcmcuaXNvLjE4MDEzLjUuMS5tRExsdmFsaWRpdHlJbmZvo2ZzaWduZWTAdDIwMjMtMTItMjlUMTY6MDE6NTdaaXZhbGlkRnJvbcB0MjAyMy0xMi0yOVQxNjowMTo1N1pqdmFsaWRVbnRpbMB0MjAyNC0xMi0yOVQxNjowMTo1N1pYQPJyDU5h4tDesMtjRzbxcm77l-np35iKtKAKQj67Vh0XRHJsNxKoX_QJRLPrL1u58HuJDbwyA6c1ewBulm4AUAM",
  "c_nonce": "LQwqEX7sT1uJkzzTdULvLsHcUvXfUaT79bkzLWEi7jw",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86256
}

The value of the credential parameter in the response is the issued mdoc. The website “CBOR Zone” (https://cbor.zone/) can be used to decode the mdoc. Copy the value of the credential parameter, paste it to the textarea of the “Input” section in the CBOR Zone, choose the base64url radio button, and press the “Generate” button. You’ll see the content of the mdoc in the CBOR Diagnostic Notation (RFC 8949, 8. Diagnostic Notation, RFC 8610, Appendix G. Extended Diagnostic Notation).

{
  "docType": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
  "issuerSigned": {
    "nameSpaces": {
      "org.iso.18013.5.1": [
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 1,
            "random": h'27a7ba79f3b55b591a6267571e3a5263',
            "elementIdentifier": "issue_date",
            "elementValue": 1004("2023-12-29")
          }
        >>),
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 2,
            "random": h'652e3d6e5569c3c811e6ce27c77f18e1',
            "elementIdentifier": "expiry_date",
            "elementValue": 1004("2024-12-29")
          }
        >>),
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 3,
            "random": h'0c47c7bf1939f3e27ed115729782b010',
            "elementIdentifier": "family_name",
            "elementValue": "Silverstone"
          }
        >>),
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 4,
            "random": h'087b23b64b49f8f9129c4a731ce3829c',
            "elementIdentifier": "given_name",
            "elementValue": "Inga"
          }
        >>),
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 5,
            "random": h'23fa0acf633690b35369f09a26e32369',
            "elementIdentifier": "birth_date",
            "elementValue": 1004("1991-11-06")
          }
        >>),
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 6,
            "random": h'1c8096c1880ca4558138cacbd02034cc',
            "elementIdentifier": "issuing_country",
            "elementValue": "US"
          }
        >>),
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 7,
            "random": h'a4895d363e331d41b0d2f71f54532c0d',
            "elementIdentifier": "document_number",
            "elementValue": "12345678"
          }
        >>),
        24(<<
          {
            "digestID": 8,
            "random": h'723f61125604cb9ddc90083830d6484c',
            "elementIdentifier": "driving_privileges",
            "elementValue": [
              {
                "vehicle_category_code": "A",
                "issue_date": 1004("2023-01-01"),
                "expiry_date": 1004("2043-01-01")
              }
            ]
          }
        >>)
      ]
    },
    "issuerAuth": [
      h'a10126',
      {
        33: h'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'
      },
      24(<<
        {
          "version": "1.0",
          "digestAlgorithm": "SHA-256",
          "valueDigests": {
            "org.iso.18013.5.1": {
              1: h'aae8adaaf2cc82a28dfe80d2a30b28a11784ee0991f81ea1f2d2df947eb55f82',
              2: h'035913b9372a8545332eeebcf5363b5da5d32834d04f2f97d024ed25b3a0a89b',
              3: h'3d2360b29e438ad6c822dcfed998264910d3c6425f10b1622675748d5eca8410',
              4: h'9edf934135f1d5ab07747f5f43465ddb21152a652c2d9688c1abaa8b579db395',
              5: h'b38a78984ada82aa5fb2c7603a9786ae6c5e06af240e9eeba557fef269e0195e',
              6: h'001a3c22502b8e8f40a75469273826b6d7bc1426d86ca8d4bc0a8c59e4159011',
              7: h'3c328283c24855f2bad8b37bb92dc0248a6394fb578996a62cc2168552901cbb',
              8: h'4d6bcbf1c0ffd7695832f8def22d93e982c4c0d24d7e37b9946ea37de4b9237d'
            }
          },
          "docType": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
          "validityInfo": {
            "signed": 0("2023-12-29T16:01:57Z"),
            "validFrom": 0("2023-12-29T16:01:57Z"),
            "validUntil": 0("2024-12-29T16:01:57Z")
          }
        }
      >>),
      h'f2720d4e61e2d0deb0cb634736f1726efb97e9e9df988ab4a00a423ebb561d1744726c3712a85ff40944b3eb2f5bb9f07b890dbc3203a7357b006e966e005003'
    ]
  }
}

4.3. POTENTIAL Interop Event / Track 1 / Light Profile

POTENTIAL is a European organization dedicated to European Digital Identity. The organization has been hosting an interoperability event since spring 2024. The event is divided into six tracks. Tracks 1 and 2 are designated for testing the inteoperability of credential issuers. In Track 1, mdoc is used as the format for verifiable credentials, while SD-JWT VC is used in Track 2. Track 1 defines two profiles. One is called the “light” profile. The other is called the “full” profile. This section explains the steps for the light profile.

4.3.1. Settings

4.3.1.1. Authorization Server Settings

Parameter	Value
Issuer Identifier	`https://trial.authlete.net`
Authorization Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/authorization`
Token Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/token`
Discovery Endpoint	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-configuration](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-configuration)`
Entity Configuration	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation)`

The source code of the authorization server is available at https://github.com/authlete/java-oauth-server. Note that this implementation is a sample and is not intended for commercial use.

4.3.1.2. Credential Issuer Settings

Parameter	Value
Issuer Identifier	`https://trial.authlete.net`
Credential Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential`
Metadata Endpoint	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-credential-issuer](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-credential-issuer)`
Entity Configuration	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation)`

The source code of the credential issuer is the same as that of the authorization server.

4.3.1.3. Client Settings

Parameter	Value
Client ID	`track1_light`
Client Type	public (= client authentication is not required)
Redirect URIs	`https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection` or `eudi-openid4ci://authorize/`

If you need to register additional redirect URIs to this client, or if you need an independent client dedicated to your use, please contact us.

To Authlete members: New clients should be created under “Trial” (organization=283415) / “NextDev” (server=2704222) / “Authlete Trial” (service=986126671).

4.3.2. Demo Steps

4.3.2.1. Step 1 : Credential Offer

The sample implementation of credential issuer provides a web page where developers can generate an arbitrary credential offer for testing. The URL of the page is https://trial.authlete.net/api/offer/issue. Accessing the web page, you will find a form to configure the content of a credential offer. Edit the form as instructed below.

Input inga and inga into the “Login ID” field and the “Password” field.
Edit the “Credential Configuration IDs”. The value should be a JSON array containing the string potential.light.profile.
Check the “include?” checkbox next to “Authorization Code Grant”.
Uncheck the “include?” checkbox next to “Pre-Authorized Code Grant”.

Potential Track1 Light Credential Offer Form

Press the “Submit” button after editing the form, and you will find a QR code that represents a URL containing the generated credential offer.

Potential Track1 Light Credential Offer Qr Code

The JSON under the QR code represents the content of the credential offer. The value of the issuer_state property in the JSON is the issued issuer state. In the above example, the value of the issuer state is tXkAkhSu5N9ORSNES9T64Bd9PAiKn9OmEOT5qDL0lkA. The issuer state is to be included in the authorization request you will make later.

4.3.2.2. Step 2 : Code Verifier and Code Challenge

Generate a code verifier and compute the corresponding code challenge (cf. RFC 7636) by using the pkce command

git clone git@github.com:authlete/oid4vci-demo.git
cd oid4vci-demo
./pkce

The pkce command will print a generated code verifier and the computed code challenge like below.

CODE_VERIFIER=gzRNlV7DLS_HyKMQKQMrzgYQ8aY3H2rVJ3iIlYK0cjE
CODE_CHALLENGE=j_4gpG9Kr3M7ilMO-MRoSROP-W3h2EZem0KSEU-RAhM

The computed code challenge is to be included in the authorization request in the next step, and the generated code verifier is to be included in the token request that will be made after the authorization request.

4.3.2.3. Step 3 : Authorization Request

Make an authorization request using the authorization code flow (cf. RFC 6749, 4.1) by inputting the following URL in the address bar of your web browser. Don’t forget to replace ${ISSUER_STATE} and ${CODE_CHALLENGE} in the URL with the actual values of the issuer state and the code challenge you have created in the previous steps.

https://trial.authlete.net/api/authorization?client_id=track1_light&response_type=code&issuer_state=${ISSUER_STATE}&redirect_uri=https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection&code_challenge=${CODE_CHALLENGE}&code_challenge_method=S256&prompt=login

Accessing the URL will show you an authorization page. The page contains a login form. Input inga and inga into the Login ID field and the Password field in the login form, and press the “Authorize” button.

Potential Track1 Light Authorization Page

You will be redirected to the redirection endpoint (cf. RFC 6749, 3.1.2).

Potential Track1 Light Redirection Endpoint

This redirection endpoint displays key-value pairs that it has received. The value of the code parameter displayed there is the issued authorization code. In this example, the value of the authorization code is gR43MQf2olvhMt6KekVDkUOdQPrVYgBiKXMwu_UFnB8. The authorization code is to be used in the token request in the next section. Note that the authorization code will expire in 10 minutes, so you have to make a token request promptly.

4.3.2.4. Step 4 : Token Request

Make a token request using the authorization code flow. Don’t forget to replace ${AUTHORIZATION_CODE} and ${CODE_VERIFIER} in the curl command below with the actual values you have obtained in the previous steps.

curl -s https://trial.authlete.net/api/token \
     -d client_id=track1_light \
     -d grant_type=authorization_code \
     -d code=${AUTHORIZATION_CODE} \
     -d redirect_uri=https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection \
     -d code_verifier=${CODE_VERIFIER}

If the token request is valid, the token endpoint returns JSON like below.

{
  "access_token": "tNR1stglRuBVUtS2sZ7tiThPcpNDENxY0LniVpRdp0E",
  "token_type": "Bearer",
  "expires_in": 86400,
  "scope": null,
  "refresh_token": "nt3ba0H42UqMBw8FMY2keDgGAF65pBHY45-kydZFmSE",
  "c_nonce": "v-1b-n82kEJGbHROSekGsmR-xEuamCxY_T0tXtQN-dY",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

The value of the access_token property in the JSON is the issued access token. It needs to be presented when you make a credential request. The value of the c_nonce property is a nonce that must be included in a key proof.

4.3.2.5. Step 5 : CWT Key Proof

The authlete/cbor library contains a utility class, CWTKeyProofBuilder, that can generate a CWT key proof. The shell script, bin/generate-cwt-key-proof, which is included in the repository of the library, is a wrapper to invoke the utility class from the command line. A CWT key proof can be generated as shown below. Don’t forget to replace ${NONCE} in the command line with the actual value of c_nonce that has been issued from the token endpoint in the previous step, and to replace ${PRIVATE_KEY_FILE} with the actual path of a file containing a private key in the JWK format (cf. RFC 7517). The file, holder.jwk, in the authlete/oid4vci-demo repository can be used for the purpose.

git clone git@github.com:authlete/cbor.git
cd cbor
mvn compile
./bin/generate-cwt-key-proof \
    --issuer https://trial.authlete.net \
    --key ${PRIVATE_KEY_FILE} \
    --client track1_light \
    --nonce ${NONCE}

The generate-cwt-key-proof script will print a CWT key proof like below.

2D3ShFifowEmA3RvcGVuaWQ0dmNpLXByb29mK2N3dGhDT1NFX0tleVh7pgECAlgrMWU1QVk5RXlCMDFYblV6YTZMcEp6azAybjZZX0FtbW5TYjBGQmVOVlZyVQMmIAEhWCA9LFCsPbOXT-ZdwCrPWaCpJ4GgGGebHbLEESmsFjwXbSJYIMVfH24tRUqLFLpy3rizbi5CYqpmOkyojJ7q_hp9sEddoFhgpAFsdHJhY2sxX2xpZ2h0A3gaaHR0cHM6Ly90cmlhbC5hdXRobGV0ZS5uZXQGGmZf3KsKWCt2LTFiLW44MmtFSkdiSFJPU2VrR3NtUi14RXVhbUN4WV9UMHRYdFFOLWRZWEDVVsA-MQ9dAiaIRThTJ5JgmND4RZuhxcIiNx04TZ7fSqlQYJlRW9AyNqXeJHIEl1KqQs_yZtlPd98kRbvziTEi

The following is the result of decoding the CWT key proof above using CBOR Zone.

61(18(/ COSE_Sign1 / [
  / protected / <<
    {
      1: -7,
      3: "openid4vci-proof+cwt",
      "COSE_Key": h'a6010202582b3165354159394579423031586e557a61364c704a7a6b30326e36595f416d6d6e5362304642654e56567255032620012158203d2c50ac3db3974fe65dc02acf59a0a92781a018679b1db2c41129ac163c176d225820c55f1f6e2d454a8b14ba72deb8b36e2e4262aa663a4ca88c9eeafe1a7db0475d'
    }
  >>,
  / unprotected / {
  },
  h'a4016c747261636b315f6c6967687403781a68747470733a2f2f747269616c2e617574686c6574652e6e6574061a665fdcab0a582b762d31622d6e38326b454a476248524f53656b47736d522d784575616d4378595f5430745874514e2d6459',
  h'd556c03e310f5d02268845385327926098d0f8459ba1c5c222371d384d9edf4aa9506099515bd03236a5de2472049752aa42cff266d94f77df2445bbf3893122'
]))

The value of COSE_Key in the protected header is a CBOR byte string, which wraps the COSE key. The content of the byte string is decoded as follows:

{
  1: 2,
  2: h'3165354159394579423031586e557a61364c704a7a6b30326e36595f416d6d6e5362304642654e56567255',
  3: -7,
  -1: 1,
  -2: h'3d2c50ac3db3974fe65dc02acf59a0a92781a018679b1db2c41129ac163c176d',
  -3: h'c55f1f6e2d454a8b14ba72deb8b36e2e4262aa663a4ca88c9eeafe1a7db0475d'
}

4.3.2.6. Step 6 : Credential Request

Make a credential request with the access token and the CWT key proof. Don’t forget to replace ${ACCESS_TOKEN} and ${CWT_KEY_PROOF} in the command line with the actual values.

curl -s https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential \
     -H "Authorization: Bearer ${ACCESS_TOKEN}" \
     -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
     --data '{
  "format": "mso_mdoc",
  "doctype": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
  "claims": {
    "org.iso.18013.5.1": {
      "family_name": {},
      "given_name": {},
      "birth_date": {},
      "issue_date": {},
      "expiry_date": {},
      "issuing_country": {},
      "document_number": {},
      "driving_privileges": {}
    }
  },
  "proof": {
    "proof_type": "cwt",
    "cwt":"'${CWT_KEY_PROOF}'"
  }
}'

If the credential request is valid, the credential endpoint returns JSON like below. The value of the credential property in the JSON is the issued verifiable credential.

{
  "credential": "ompuYW1lU3BhY2VzoXFvcmcuaXNvLjE4MDEzLjUuMYjYGFhbpGhkaWdlc3RJRAFmcmFuZG9tUEJDfxiBFQGMwsBY7jE6mkdxZWxlbWVudElkZW50aWZpZXJqaXNzdWVfZGF0ZWxlbGVtZW50VmFsdWXZA-xqMjAyNC0wNi0wNdgYWFykaGRpZ2VzdElEAmZyYW5kb21QuWRGth4zjRXOJN_iGNTy0nFlbGVtZW50SWRlbnRpZmllcmtleHBpcnlfZGF0ZWxlbGVtZW50VmFsdWXZA-xqMjAyNS0wNi0wNdgYWFqkaGRpZ2VzdElEA2ZyYW5kb21Q7Zx7xYZtB0D02nL-x0UGFXFlbGVtZW50SWRlbnRpZmllcmtmYW1pbHlfbmFtZWxlbGVtZW50VmFsdWVrU2lsdmVyc3RvbmXYGFhSpGhkaWdlc3RJRARmcmFuZG9tUPMV5L8B03Uuj0GRMFZvWpJxZWxlbWVudElkZW50aWZpZXJqZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZWxlbGVtZW50VmFsdWVkSW5nYdgYWFukaGRpZ2VzdElEBWZyYW5kb21Q3fLHe4K4bUMJDFsSYKJ513FlbGVtZW50SWRlbnRpZmllcmpiaXJ0aF9kYXRlbGVsZW1lbnRWYWx1ZdkD7GoxOTkxLTExLTA22BhYVaRoZGlnZXN0SUQGZnJhbmRvbVDIzuaMNAe24KBZ3QQpP5o8cWVsZW1lbnRJZGVudGlmaWVyb2lzc3VpbmdfY291bnRyeWxlbGVtZW50VmFsdWViVVPYGFhbpGhkaWdlc3RJRAdmcmFuZG9tUJV-wSoCvKEqVh_g3844LmdxZWxlbWVudElkZW50aWZpZXJvZG9jdW1lbnRfbnVtYmVybGVsZW1lbnRWYWx1ZWgxMjM0NTY3ONgYWKKkaGRpZ2VzdElECGZyYW5kb21QZHMJeAleAPyXtFA-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-yTFUODDAKBggqhkjOPQQDAgNHADBEAiBnFjScBcvERleLjMCu5NbxJKkNsa_gQhkXTfDmbq-T3gIgVazbsVdQvZgluc9nJYQxWlzXT9i6f-wgUKx0KCYbj3BZArLYGFkCraZndmVyc2lvbmMxLjBvZGlnZXN0QWxnb3JpdGhtZ1NIQS0yNTZsdmFsdWVEaWdlc3RzoXFvcmcuaXNvLjE4MDEzLjUuMagBWCBtyGKRLbYNCtXpIqSixji4RYcXb4Vf7IDoQta4QfRWsAJYIJVrdxQWwcfqiFi75y5R3Saj8YpA8miZxmeoQL_JtB5-A1ggnoXpxMgIsgiIr8HlJ9JzfalESFVLgFxmES9SqSIsIG0EWCD-4Mo98S8qg8SJ8R-PMO7oCHW3wbdCfU8GGS0nG7VahwVYIE9yvCITC8M8p7-m2M4A5MwokXN3oS97uLkhk2AIj6GRBlgg8IaPGI_7Tp2rf2fLhEq0dDzm71FmTZUPc16BdJsCDgkHWCAKnWjJaTmwvgq1Yon8cLwPaPS1-lOEVASldrxYkeKLcwhYIEXVTVGxIhP9R64iPFGseCD_adyfhYZdCw-eOO8ckRjzbWRldmljZUtleUluZm-iaWRldmljZUtleaYBAgJYKzFlNUFZOUV5QjAxWG5VemE2THBKemswMm42WV9BbW1uU2IwRkJlTlZWclUDJiABIVggPSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20iWCDFXx9uLUVKixS6ct64s24uQmKqZjpMqIye6v4afbBHXXFrZXlBdXRob3JpemF0aW9uc6FqbmFtZVNwYWNlc4Fxb3JnLmlzby4xODAxMy41LjFnZG9jVHlwZXVvcmcuaXNvLjE4MDEzLjUuMS5tRExsdmFsaWRpdHlJbmZvo2ZzaWduZWTAdDIwMjQtMDYtMDVUMDM6MzU6MTRaaXZhbGlkRnJvbcB0MjAyNC0wNi0wNVQwMzozNToxNFpqdmFsaWRVbnRpbMB0MjAyNS0wNi0wNVQwMzozNToxNFpYQAs0d0MAErcaA1auodhHxivYcqiSXdQW9KtG9HpZoxo_oEPfkf7_dRQm_Z-ffhZn2qbLTc2Op3x0a1R-gif9Mtg",
  "c_nonce": "v-1b-n82kEJGbHROSekGsmR-xEuamCxY_T0tXtQN-dY",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86205
}

4.3.3. Verifiable Credential Format

The CBOR Diagnostic Notation representation of the verifiable credential in the previous section is as follows.

{
  "nameSpaces": {
    "org.iso.18013.5.1": [
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 1,
          "random": h'42437f188115018cc2c058ee313a9a47',
          "elementIdentifier": "issue_date",
          "elementValue": 1004("2024-06-05")
        }
      >>),
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 2,
          "random": h'b96446b61e338d15ce24dfe218d4f2d2',
          "elementIdentifier": "expiry_date",
          "elementValue": 1004("2025-06-05")
        }
      >>),
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 3,
          "random": h'ed9c7bc5866d0740f4da72fec7450615',
          "elementIdentifier": "family_name",
          "elementValue": "Silverstone"
        }
      >>),
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 4,
          "random": h'f315e4bf01d3752e8f419130566f5a92',
          "elementIdentifier": "given_name",
          "elementValue": "Inga"
        }
      >>),
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 5,
          "random": h'ddf2c77b82b86d43090c5b1260a279d7',
          "elementIdentifier": "birth_date",
          "elementValue": 1004("1991-11-06")
        }
      >>),
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 6,
          "random": h'c8cee68c3407b6e0a059dd04293f9a3c',
          "elementIdentifier": "issuing_country",
          "elementValue": "US"
        }
      >>),
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 7,
          "random": h'957ec12a02bca12a561fe0dfce382e67',
          "elementIdentifier": "document_number",
          "elementValue": "12345678"
        }
      >>),
      24(<<
        {
          "digestID": 8,
          "random": h'64730978095e00fc97b4503e4e25810f',
          "elementIdentifier": "driving_privileges",
          "elementValue": [
            {
              "vehicle_category_code": "A",
              "issue_date": 1004("2023-01-01"),
              "expiry_date": 1004("2043-01-01")
            }
          ]
        }
      >>)
    ]
  },
  "issuerAuth": [
    h'a10126',
    {
      33: h'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'
    },
    h'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',
    h'0b3477430012b71a0356aea1d847c62bd872a8925dd416f4ab46f47a59a31a3fa043df91feff751426fd9f9f7e1667daa6cb4dcd8ea77c746b547e8227fd32d8'
  ]
}

In this example, the verifiable credential represents the IssuerSigned structure, which is defined in the “8.3.2.1.2.2 Device retrieval mdoc response” section of ISO/IEC 18013-5:2021 as below.

IssuerSigned = {
  ? "nameSpaces" : IssuerNameSpaces,
  "issuerAuth" : IssuerAuth
}

Unexpectedly, the OID4VCI specification does not specify which CBOR structure the value of the credential property represents when the format is mso_mdoc. This is unlikely to be intentional and is simply a specification flaw.Due to this ambiguity, in the previous implementation of Authlete, the Document structure was used instead of the IssuerSigned structure. Interestingly, it appears that the implementation of EUDI Wallet expects neither the IssuerSigned structure nor the Document structure. Instead, it seems to expect the DeviceResponse structure.The reason for changing the implementation of Authlete to use the IssuerSigned structure is because the document for POTENTIAL Interop Event Track 1 explicitly states that the IssuerSigned structure should be used.

And, the IssuerAuth structure and some other relevant structures are defined as below.

IssuerAuth = COSE_Sign1 ; The payload is MobileSecurityObjectBytes

MobileSecurityObjectBytes = #6.24(bstr .cbor MobileSecurityObject)

MobileSecurityObject = {
    "version" : tstr, ; Version of the MobileSecurityObject
    "digestAlgorithm" : tstr, ; Message digest algorithm used
    "valueDigests" : ValueDigests, ; Digests of all data elements per namespace
    "deviceKeyInfo" : DeviceKeyInfo,
    "docType" : tstr, ; docType as used in Documents
    "validityInfo" : ValidityInfo
}

DeviceKeyInfo = {
    "deviceKey" : DeviceKey
    ? "keyAuthorizations" : KeyAuthorizations,
    ? "keyInfo" : KeyInfo
}

DeviceKey = COSE_Key

The definitions of IssuerAuth and MobileSecurityObjectBytes give the impression that MobileSecurityObjectBytes (which starts with a CBOR tag) is directly used as the payload of COSE_Sign1. However, it is necessary to further convert MobileSecurityObjectBytes into a byte string. Therefore, the third element in the "issuerAuth" array, which starts with h'd81859, represents a byte string containing MobileSecurityObjectBytes. You can see the following CBOR structure by decoding that byte string.

24(<<
  {
    "version": "1.0",
    "digestAlgorithm": "SHA-256",
    "valueDigests": {
      "org.iso.18013.5.1": {
        1: h'6dc862912db60d0ad5e922a4a2c638b84587176f855fec80e842d6b841f456b0',
        2: h'956b771416c1c7ea8858bbe72e51dd26a3f18a40f26899c667a840bfc9b41e7e',
        3: h'9e85e9c4c808b20888afc1e527d2737da94448554b805c66112f52a9222c206d',
        4: h'fee0ca3df12f2a83c489f11f8f30eee80875b7c1b7427d4f06192d271bb55a87',
        5: h'4f72bc22130bc33ca7bfa6d8ce00e4cc28917377a12f7bb8b9219360088fa191',
        6: h'f0868f188ffb4e9dab7f67cb844ab4743ce6ef51664d950f735e81749b020e09',
        7: h'0a9d68c96939b0be0ab56289fc70bc0f68f4b5fa53845404a576bc5891e28b73',
        8: h'45d54d51b12213fd47ae223c51ac7820ff69dc9f85865d0b0f9e38ef1c9118f3'
      }
    },
    "deviceKeyInfo": {
      "deviceKey": {
        1: 2,
        2: h'3165354159394579423031586e557a61364c704a7a6b30326e36595f416d6d6e5362304642654e56567255',
        3: -7,
        -1: 1,
        -2: h'3d2c50ac3db3974fe65dc02acf59a0a92781a018679b1db2c41129ac163c176d',
        -3: h'c55f1f6e2d454a8b14ba72deb8b36e2e4262aa663a4ca88c9eeafe1a7db0475d'
      },
      "keyAuthorizations": {
        "nameSpaces": [
          "org.iso.18013.5.1"
        ]
      }
    },
    "docType": "org.iso.18013.5.1.mDL",
    "validityInfo": {
      "signed": 0("2024-06-05T03:35:14Z"),
      "validFrom": 0("2024-06-05T03:35:14Z"),
      "validUntil": 0("2025-06-05T03:35:14Z")
    }
  }
>>)

The point to note is that the public key embedded in the CWT key proof appears in the verifiable credential as the value of deviceKey. Please confirm that the value of COSE_Key in the CWT key proof is identical to the value of deviceKey in the VC. Both hold the following COSE Key.

{
  / kty /  1:  2 / EC2 /,
  / kid /  2: h'3165354159394579423031586e557a61364c704a7a6b30326e36595f416d6d6e5362304642654e56567255',
  / alg /  3: -7 / ES256 /,
  / crv / -1:  1 / P-256 /,
  /  x  / -2: h'3d2c50ac3db3974fe65dc02acf59a0a92781a018679b1db2c41129ac163c176d',
  /  y  / -3: h'c55f1f6e2d454a8b14ba72deb8b36e2e4262aa663a4ca88c9eeafe1a7db0475d'
}

Refer to IANA: CBOR Object Signing and Encryption (COSE) for the meanings of the integer labels and integer values in the COSE Key.

4.4. POTENTIAL Interop Event / Track 2 / Light Profile

POTENTIAL is a European organization dedicated to European Digital Identity. The organization has been hosting an interoperability event since spring 2024. The event is divided into six tracks. Tracks 1 and 2 are designated for testing the inteoperability of credential issuers. In Track 1, mdoc is used as the format for verifiable credentials, while SD-JWT VC is used in Track 2. Track 2 defines two profiles. One is called the “light” profile. The other is called the “full” profile. This section explains the steps for the light profile.

4.4.1. Settings

4.4.1.1. Authorization Server Settings

Parameter	Value
Issuer Identifier	`https://trial.authlete.net`
Authorization Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/authorization`
Token Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/token`
Discovery Endpoint	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-configuration](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-configuration)`
Entity Configuration	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation)`

The source code of the authorization server is available at https://github.com/authlete/java-oauth-server. Note that this implementation is a sample and is not intended for commercial use.

4.4.1.2. Credential Issuer Settings

Parameter	Value
Issuer Identifier	`https://trial.authlete.net`
Credential Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential`
Metadata Endpoint	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-credential-issuer](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-credential-issuer)`
Entity Configuration	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation)`

The source code of the credential issuer is the same as that of the authorization server.

4.4.1.3. Client Settings

Parameter	Value
Client ID	`track2_light`
Client Type	public (= client authentication is not required)
Redirect URIs	`https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection` or `eudi-openid4ci://authorize/`

If you need to register additional redirect URIs to this client, or if you need an independent client dedicated to your use, please contact us.

To Authlete members: New clients should be created under “Trial” (organization=283415) / “NextDev” (server=2704222) / “Authlete Trial” (service=986126671).

4.4.2. Demo Steps

4.4.2.1. Step 1 : Code Verifier and Code Challenge

Generate a code verifier and compute the corresponding code challenge (cf. RFC 7636) by using the pkce command

git clone git@github.com:authlete/oid4vci-demo.git
cd oid4vci-demo
./pkce

The pkce command will print a generated code verifier and the computed code challenge like below.

CODE_VERIFIER=gzRNlV7DLS_HyKMQKQMrzgYQ8aY3H2rVJ3iIlYK0cjE
CODE_CHALLENGE=j_4gpG9Kr3M7ilMO-MRoSROP-W3h2EZem0KSEU-RAhM

4.4.2.2. Step 2 : Authorization Request

Make an authorization request using the authorization code flow (cf. RFC 6749, 4.1) by inputting the following URL in the address bar of your web browser. Don’t forget to replace ${CODE_CHALLENGE} in the URL with the actual value of the code challenge you have created in the previous step.

https://trial.authlete.net/api/authorization?client_id=track2_light&response_type=code&scope=potential.track2.light.profile&redirect_uri=https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection&code_challenge=${CODE_CHALLENGE}&code_challenge_method=S256&prompt=login

Potential Track2 Light Authorization Page

You will be redirected to the redirection endpoint (cf. RFC 6749, 3.1.2).

4.4.2.3. Step 3 : Token Request

curl -s https://trial.authlete.net/api/token \
     -d client_id=track2_light \
     -d grant_type=authorization_code \
     -d code=${AUTHORIZATION_CODE} \
     -d redirect_uri=https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection \
     -d code_verifier=${CODE_VERIFIER}

If the token request is valid, the token endpoint returns JSON like below.

{
  "access_token": "FvF1eeUbbWwteF5v0nfsO6vb0jlWifgsP5U666qKSGs",
  "token_type": "Bearer",
  "expires_in": 86400,
  "scope": "potential.track2.light.profile",
  "refresh_token": "WUCNjsuU02XhOMWN5qHRkKKbZDX5g2HjJx52GWC_1Gw",
  "c_nonce": "rvw3Mo_ZHyEgYOoWQ9GEotemwFbhRvVVdI6e5Z0lhEs",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

4.4.2.4. Step 4 : JWT Key Proof

Generate a JWT Key Proof using the holder key holder.jwk and the generate-key-proof script. The JWK file and the script are contained in the oid4vci-demo repository. Don’t forget to replace $C_NONCE in the following command line with the actual value of the c_nonce property in the token response you received in the previous step.

./generate-key-proof \
    -i https://trial.authlete.net \
    -k holder.jwk \
    -c track2_light \
    -n $C_NONCE

The generate-key-proof script will generate a JWT Key Proof like below.

eyJ0eXAiOiJvcGVuaWQ0dmNpLXByb29mK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiUFN4UXJEMnpsMF9tWGNBcXoxbWdxU2VCb0Jobm14Mnl4QkVwckJZOEYyMCIsInkiOiJ4VjhmYmkxRlNvc1V1bkxldUxOdUxrSmlxbVk2VEtpTW51ci1HbjJ3UjEwIn19.eyJpc3MiOiJ0cmFjazJfbGlnaHQiLCJhdWQiOiJodHRwczovL3RyaWFsLmF1dGhsZXRlLm5ldCIsImlhdCI6MTcxNzYxNzk1Nywibm9uY2UiOiJydnczTW9fWkh5RWdZT29XUTlHRW90ZW13RmJoUnZWVmRJNmU1WjBsaEVzIn0.E-9pdaSW2oaFqI2V0N1aRiSRI3LzOxwQFNR5tewaLXxP8R7ZHrU9-M7TLuqP5OmWRecdFrJ9yQAM83kbc4f5-A

Decoding the header and the payload of the JWT Key Proof by base64url will show the following JSONs.

{
  "typ": "openid4vci-proof+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "PSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20",
    "y": "xV8fbi1FSosUunLeuLNuLkJiqmY6TKiMnur-Gn2wR10"
  }
}

{
  "iss": "track2_light",
  "aud": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "iat": 1717617957,
  "nonce": "rvw3Mo_ZHyEgYOoWQ9GEotemwFbhRvVVdI6e5Z0lhEs"
}

The result of executing the generate-key-proof script can be directly set to the shell variable JWT_KEY_PROOF by doing the following.

JWT_KEY_PROOF=`./generate-key-proof -i https://trial.authlete.net -k holder.jwk -c track2_light -n $C_NONCE`

4.4.2.5. Step 5 : Credential Request

Make a credential request with the access token and the JWT key proof. Don’t forget to replace ${ACCESS_TOKEN} and ${JWT_KEY_PROOF} in the command line with the actual values.

curl -s https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential \
     -H "Authorization: Bearer ${ACCESS_TOKEN}" \
     -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
       --data '{
  "format": "vc+sd-jwt",
  "vct": "urn:eu.europa.ec.eudi:pid:1",
  "proof": {
    "proof_type": "jwt",
    "jwt":"'${JWT_KEY_PROOF}'"
  }
}'

If the credential request is valid, the credential endpoint returns JSON like below. The value of the credential property in the JSON is the issued verifiable credential.

{
  "credential": "eyJraWQiOiJKMUZ3SlA4N0M2LVFOX1dTSU9tSkFRYzZuNUNRX2JaZGFGSjVHRG5XMVJrIiwidHlwIjoidmMrc2Qtand0IiwiYWxnIjoiRVMyNTYifQ.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.EaUDXo2hWBNOqsdYBDAWpuHDYfGm9xNepZJn7rafTGAb3kHVxNJoSZTvOvLhk_sy30GpK2kLFWvVlR1nzxSMVg~WyJyeHR0ck5MbXUwNWc5cjVZVmc3bUtnIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd~WyJaR2lyT3Y3dUdLVXZOWUpVcFZ0QXJBIiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd~WyIwcGt4eEVwVmIwdW5mQUQ1R1VsZXVnIiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ~WyI2RWtWSGN2U0lIZ215akE0VW5fZlNRIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd~WyJhUzhNbVlFWHVWR1A5ODYwQV9lZDZRIiwiMTgiLHRydWVd~WyJMX1JRdm00Mll0XzdESHVjTi1IUHRRIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd~WyJmQmpkVWRTV0NBX0o4NXF2anlmcXVBIiwiZm9ybWF0dGVkIiwiMTE0IE9sZCBTdGF0ZSBId3kgMTI3LCBTaG9zaG9uZSwgQ0EgOTIzODQsIFVTQSJd~WyJIOGVpZ0UxckQ2d3o3RDA3b0pnNjl3Iiwic3RyZWV0X2FkZHJlc3MiLCIxMTQgT2xkIFN0YXRlIEh3eSAxMjciXQ~WyIxdngwVjJmTUVrTTBXNnVCYWg5VjRBIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd~WyJHVnZfZWV0VElPLW93NTgzRTRMSDBBIiwicG9zdGFsX2NvZGUiLCJDQSA5MjM4NCJd~WyJrYjJYUkhsMTQxazFyZG1xeGdDM2xRIiwiY291bnRyeSIsIlVTQSJd~WyJLU0VlbEV0dU5qbzZHQWR6NTFqSG93IiwiaXNzdWluZ19hdXRob3JpdHkiLCJVUyJd~WyJ0ZzBZQ3RNeHNPSW54aW9pUExDNV93IiwiaXNzdWluZ19jb3VudHJ5IiwiVVMiXQ~",
  "c_nonce": "rvw3Mo_ZHyEgYOoWQ9GEotemwFbhRvVVdI6e5Z0lhEs",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 83596
}

4.4.3. Verifiable Credential Format

./decode-sd-jwt $SD_JWT

The result will look like below.

{
  "kid": "J1FwJP87C6-QN_WSIOmJAQc6n5CQ_bZdaFJ5GDnW1Rk",
  "typ": "vc+sd-jwt",
  "alg": "ES256"
}
{
  "place_of_birth": {
    "_sd": [
      "EAbAmR7Z07Wi1W3s6KITN0WajasQ9NlBfbohr8-Sx_s",
      "bBg_MIiJ6raMOcgGDwfmIALHJEScILC2F8BNjNUmLto"
    ]
  },
  "_sd": [
    "1A8fFbJ1Ya3tfCvDQzK4sLIHLDRDEbDbMhPEfp_SG5U",
    "28jL7wHUtq0n1wZAJfcWhL5NZKyBkL0TU3siiSOlezY",
    "2cr_E536qMQ00wgPS1D_lvreAasmmspxaNvOQ_wvmLA",
    "5uq6z-wAhZeBD2KwV1N5NeqDjIjWTzjB-1UOujvNRYY",
    "6waVTKzVi1fh1LPsF_mDJubkraadjgPKXMGI7PznV0g",
    "78rctRsmEanWZ2nvOTWr5YoXFyyntfIq1MN8jumrB8o",
    "88vwsUUlr5FabPhO5XacwHtngMuSv4DVa_kA99E1kys",
    "9GzaN1eg56W3TCxhlp9fKSOwHS_nhDxF1VrSlH7gq1E",
    "BwZFQTCjVM1EnHsUHyt3grcthV2RHVqdLbTv3--Ek8g",
    "Ed7UlXXKK2uwlnRMtzRdtg8T0mWnQxA9UNnPetKuOuc",
    "FNzxWfHda7HWpGdAjI3TwZxWxNXGLp4wjpGu_CjGAXc",
    "GnIFF8X9NZBmTJCa99LxPQROG5c6XQk2zbu4ocln9Ik",
    "LsflpqTLX8OJXbNwy7qp570tJcB9OGPxOjMLDSmAQ2I",
    "dsJV0Ggb_fUcxiOjToUIChJFGQyhRLdzvYimBceI3zc",
    "h2vSwQStI_KpkqSWc7MuLn8VPykEczREZ3DgXTwt33Q",
    "jCIxgIdcbNRuCmBCx_CAT0gaoeDBSoUByx_7_DU1Bdo",
    "kteHiYvX_mjaGK4bE8b62FKgRvvlTBMSq-xiVRPe0zQ",
    "pyurk5OsxkXKahgidmwkMNz50TikF-_3FF4XoRbX4l4",
    "vTw9VZR8ZMAm3ZHqdbq5PqIPAgC6mYrXaxbadzAP8jY"
  ],
  "address": {
    "_sd": [
      "0WaBkKu8CYOWSev1CM8laSpKuBm6RMmhvKRGy2Ydcic",
      "Mm7V_WWE8UJMSHuti_1wCaoJn-LJq7ZXnEH65uu1E9k",
      "PVJbaff5sZbBbmGcgdEgN9vlMdguOZj_225XRM1LtwE",
      "iQOZA7dWAeTi85DMQCStRi2JusHpzaRD7AUEvOA2V7U",
      "m0eabQ2L5bLEOcu0b4QNFPycoLynP03bLhFosMWKytQ",
      "mutMOZ-X1BThzs69wqCq7DTbxqJ64gXoXolGnzr9Ifg",
      "nKitOKwA5ohgD-6uO4DH1o0Bth7KVJwIiyUIH_rbK-E",
      "rBMyRTzLVdA_ncoul3KzsuqYnalK_IgaaLWFwi-x27s",
      "u82QxDzlrEYlAiR5EulbwebRhSgaeZgJ9vA2Fgx3voU"
    ]
  },
  "vct": "urn:eu.europa.ec.eudi:pid:1",
  "_sd_alg": "sha-256",
  "iss": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "cnf": {
    "jwk": {
      "kty": "EC",
      "crv": "P-256",
      "kid": "4M9kIrB9WYzt1GQgL12lzdBZsGyeV3lgPKov28oT5L4",
      "x": "PSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20",
      "y": "xV8fbi1FSosUunLeuLNuLkJiqmY6TKiMnur-Gn2wR10"
    }
  },
  "iat": 1717618661,
  "age_equal_or_over": {
    "_sd": [
      "3dj65zN133KhZ7T0WTbtw3IXbjXxTtHeKh2TV9bU34c",
      "DRT6--Sf-458lcZ8GhlgyMNSeEr4trktueXd5ss4kOE"
    ]
  }
}
{
  "digest": "GnIFF8X9NZBmTJCa99LxPQROG5c6XQk2zbu4ocln9Ik",
  "WyJyeHR0ck5MbXUwNWc5cjVZVmc3bUtnIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd": [
    "rxttrNLmu05g9r5YVg7mKg",
    "sub",
    "1004"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "jCIxgIdcbNRuCmBCx_CAT0gaoeDBSoUByx_7_DU1Bdo",
  "WyJaR2lyT3Y3dUdLVXZOWUpVcFZ0QXJBIiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd": [
    "ZGirOv7uGKUvNYJUpVtArA",
    "family_name",
    "Silverstone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "h2vSwQStI_KpkqSWc7MuLn8VPykEczREZ3DgXTwt33Q",
  "WyIwcGt4eEVwVmIwdW5mQUQ1R1VsZXVnIiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ": [
    "0pkxxEpVb0unfAD5GUleug",
    "given_name",
    "Inga"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "dsJV0Ggb_fUcxiOjToUIChJFGQyhRLdzvYimBceI3zc",
  "WyI2RWtWSGN2U0lIZ215akE0VW5fZlNRIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd": [
    "6EkVHcvSIHgmyjA4Un_fSQ",
    "birthdate",
    "1991-11-06"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "DRT6--Sf-458lcZ8GhlgyMNSeEr4trktueXd5ss4kOE",
  "WyJhUzhNbVlFWHVWR1A5ODYwQV9lZDZRIiwiMTgiLHRydWVd": [
    "aS8MmYEXuVGP9860A_ed6Q",
    "18",
    true
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "EAbAmR7Z07Wi1W3s6KITN0WajasQ9NlBfbohr8-Sx_s",
  "WyJMX1JRdm00Mll0XzdESHVjTi1IUHRRIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd": [
    "L_RQvm42Yt_7DHucN-HPtQ",
    "locality",
    "Shoshone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "rBMyRTzLVdA_ncoul3KzsuqYnalK_IgaaLWFwi-x27s",
  "WyJmQmpkVWRTV0NBX0o4NXF2anlmcXVBIiwiZm9ybWF0dGVkIiwiMTE0IE9sZCBTdGF0ZSBId3kgMTI3LCBTaG9zaG9uZSwgQ0EgOTIzODQsIFVTQSJd": [
    "fBjdUdSWCA_J85qvjyfquA",
    "formatted",
    "114 Old State Hwy 127, Shoshone, CA 92384, USA"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "iQOZA7dWAeTi85DMQCStRi2JusHpzaRD7AUEvOA2V7U",
  "WyJIOGVpZ0UxckQ2d3o3RDA3b0pnNjl3Iiwic3RyZWV0X2FkZHJlc3MiLCIxMTQgT2xkIFN0YXRlIEh3eSAxMjciXQ": [
    "H8eigE1rD6wz7D07oJg69w",
    "street_address",
    "114 Old State Hwy 127"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "Mm7V_WWE8UJMSHuti_1wCaoJn-LJq7ZXnEH65uu1E9k",
  "WyIxdngwVjJmTUVrTTBXNnVCYWg5VjRBIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd": [
    "1vx0V2fMEkM0W6uBah9V4A",
    "locality",
    "Shoshone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "PVJbaff5sZbBbmGcgdEgN9vlMdguOZj_225XRM1LtwE",
  "WyJHVnZfZWV0VElPLW93NTgzRTRMSDBBIiwicG9zdGFsX2NvZGUiLCJDQSA5MjM4NCJd": [
    "GVv_eetTIO-ow583E4LH0A",
    "postal_code",
    "CA 92384"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "m0eabQ2L5bLEOcu0b4QNFPycoLynP03bLhFosMWKytQ",
  "WyJrYjJYUkhsMTQxazFyZG1xeGdDM2xRIiwiY291bnRyeSIsIlVTQSJd": [
    "kb2XRHl141k1rdmqxgC3lQ",
    "country",
    "USA"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "88vwsUUlr5FabPhO5XacwHtngMuSv4DVa_kA99E1kys",
  "WyJLU0VlbEV0dU5qbzZHQWR6NTFqSG93IiwiaXNzdWluZ19hdXRob3JpdHkiLCJVUyJd": [
    "KSEelEtuNjo6GAdz51jHow",
    "issuing_authority",
    "US"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "kteHiYvX_mjaGK4bE8b62FKgRvvlTBMSq-xiVRPe0zQ",
  "WyJ0ZzBZQ3RNeHNPSW54aW9pUExDNV93IiwiaXNzdWluZ19jb3VudHJ5IiwiVVMiXQ": [
    "tg0YCtMxsOInxioiPLC5_w",
    "issuing_country",
    "US"
  ]
}

4.5. POTENTIAL Interop Event / Track 2 / Full Profile

POTENTIAL is a European organization dedicated to European Digital Identity. The organization has been hosting an interoperability event since spring 2024. The event is divided into six tracks. Tracks 1 and 2 are designated for testing the inteoperability of credential issuers. In Track 1, mdoc is used as the format for verifiable credentials, while SD-JWT VC is used in Track 2. Track 2 defines two profiles. One is called the “light” profile. The other is called the “full” profile. This section explains the steps for the full profile.

4.5.1. Settings

4.5.1.1. Authorization Server Settings

Parameter	Value
Issuer Identifier	`https://trial.authlete.net`
Authorization Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/authorization`
Token Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/token`
PAR Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/par`
Discovery Endpoint	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-configuration](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-configuration)`
Entity Configuration	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation)`

The source code of the authorization server is available at https://github.com/authlete/java-oauth-server. Note that this implementation is a sample and is not intended for commercial use.

4.5.1.2. Credential Issuer Settings

Parameter	Value
Issuer Identifier	`https://trial.authlete.net`
Credential Endpoint	`https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential`
Metadata Endpoint	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-credential-issuer](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-credential-issuer)`
Entity Configuration	`[https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation](https://trial.authlete.net/.well-known/openid-federation)`

The source code of the credential issuer is the same as that of the authorization server.

4.5.1.3. Client Settings

Parameter	Value
Client ID	`track2_full`
Client Type	confidential
Client Authentication Method	`attest_jwt_client_auth`
Redirect URIs	`https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection` or `eudi-openid4ci://authorize/`

If you need to register additional redirect URIs to this client, or if you need an independent client dedicated to your use, please contact us.

To Authlete members: New clients should be created under “Trial” (organization=283415) / “NextDev” (server=2704222) / “Authlete Trial” (service=986126671).

4.5.2. Demo Steps

4.5.2.1. Step 1 : Code Verifier and Code Challenge

Generate a code verifier and compute the corresponding code challenge (cf. RFC 7636) by using the pkce command

git clone git@github.com:authlete/oid4vci-demo.git
cd oid4vci-demo
./pkce

The pkce command will print a generated code verifier and the computed code challenge like below.

CODE_VERIFIER=gzRNlV7DLS_HyKMQKQMrzgYQ8aY3H2rVJ3iIlYK0cjE
CODE_CHALLENGE=j_4gpG9Kr3M7ilMO-MRoSROP-W3h2EZem0KSEU-RAhM

The computed code challenge is to be included in the PAR request (RFC 9126), and the generated code verifier is to be included in the token request, which will be made later.

4.5.2.2. Step 2 : Client Attestation and Client Attestation PoP

In POTENTIAL’s Track 2 Full Profile, a new client authentication method called “OAuth 2.0 Attestation-Based Client Authentication” is used. For this method, two JWTs need to be prepared. The JWTs are called “Client Attestation” and “Client Attestation PoP”, respectively. The oid4vci-demo repository includes two scripts, generate-client-attestation and generate-client-attestation-pop, for generating the JWTs. Their usage is as follows:

Usage: generate-client-attestation [options]
        --attester-id=ATTESTER_ID    The identifier of the client attestation issuer.
        --attester-key=FILE          The file containing the private key of the client attestation issuer in the JWK format.
        --client-id=CLIENT_ID        The identifier of the client application.
        --client-key=FILE            The file containing the public key of the client application in the JWK format.
        --duration=DURATION          The duration of the client attestation in seconds. The default value is 86400.

Usage: generate-client-attestation-pop [options]
        --as-id=AS_ID                The identifier of the authorization server.
        --client-id=CLIENT_ID        The identifier of the client application.
        --client-key=FILE            The file containing the private key of the client application in the JWK format.
        --duration=DURATION          The duration of the client attestation PoP in seconds. The default value is 86400.

To generate a client attestation, a private key of the “client attestation issuer” (hereinafter referred to as “attester”) and a public key of the client application are needed. The attester’s key is used for signing the client attestation. The client’s key is embedded in the client attestation. The oid4vci-demo repository includes an attester’s private key (attester.jwk) and a client’s private key (client.jwk) for demo. With these keys, a client attestation can be generated as follows:

./generate-client-attestation \
    --attester-id=https://attester.example.com \
    --attester-key=attester.jwk \
    --client-id=track2_full \
    --client-key=client.jwk

The generate-client-attestation script uses only the public part of the specified client key, even if a private key is given. Therefore, the file containing the private key of the client can be passed to the --client-key option directly.

The above example uses https://attester.example.com as the value of the attester’s identifier. Any value works because the current implementation of Authlete does not care about the value.Please note that the current draft (draft 03 as of this writing) of the “OAuth 2.0 Attestation-Based Client Authentication” specification does not specify how to obtain the public key for verifying the signature of a client attestation. It seems that the specification expects ecosystems to determine their own rules for that part, respectively.Therefore, the current implementation of Authlete does NOT verify the signature of a client attestation, and so Authlete does not care about the value of the attester’s identifier. Verification of the signature of a client attestation must be done by the implementation of your authorization server.In the future, Authlete may provide mechanisms to aid in the verification step.

The generate-client-attestation script generates a client attestation in the JWT format like below:

eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJFUzI1NiIsImtpZCI6InpYOXhiSnFCemlNV0s1dm1qWEhnWlRtaVkxNnhmblp4elNFYTBHcVk1X1EifQ.eyJpc3MiOiJodHRwczovL2F0dGVzdGVyLmV4YW1wbGUuY29tIiwic3ViIjoidHJhY2syX2Z1bGwiLCJpYXQiOjE3MTk0NzMzNTIsImV4cCI6MTcxOTU1OTc1MiwiY25mIjp7Imp3ayI6eyJjcnYiOiJQLTI1NiIsImt0eSI6IkVDIiwieCI6IjFBbVZyNEdvSGRQZ2s0OExXZFMzVDltNm0xbVA0VlRjajl1c29TQm5DUWsiLCJ5IjoidGUtV0l1VUlxMnc4dFhtWHlkbEVYNHBlOWxOZS1QQmNvekE4bjd5OFhURSJ9fX0._jNM-9vEL14AOJrfk03ipIi7YECL-SGXUvqtdSiaYKVGhq7AK15QiqzzIwBj92Lij7Y4DvrtGix-0Pf4hwhPmQ

The following is the base64url-decoded header and payload of the JWT. You can see that the attester’s identifier is used as the value of the iss claim and the public key of the client is embedded as the value of the cnf.jwk property.

{
  "typ": "JWT",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "kid": "zX9xbJqBziMWK5vmjXHgZTmiY16xfnZxzSEa0GqY5_Q"
}

{
  "iss": "https://attester.example.com",
  "sub": "track2_full",
  "iat": 1719473352,
  "exp": 1719559752,
  "cnf": {
    "jwk": {
      "crv": "P-256",
      "kty": "EC",
      "x": "1AmVr4GoHdPgk48LWdS3T9m6m1mP4VTcj9usoSBnCQk",
      "y": "te-WIuUIq2w8tXmXydlEX4pe9lNe-PBcozA8n7y8XTE"
    }
  }
}

To generate a client attestation PoP, a private key of the client is needed. The client’s key is used for signing the client attestation PoP. With the client’s private key (client.jwk) in the oid4vci-demo repository, a client attestation PoP can be generated as follows:

./generate-client-attestation-pop \
    --as-id=https://trial.authlete.net \
    --client-id=track2_full \
    --client-key=client.jwk

The generate-client-attestation-pop script generates a client attestation PoP in the JWT format like below:

eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJFUzI1NiIsImtpZCI6Ijd5TmhJSFZlYVBGSUJfMGstWXBpRkFUb21DTHB4SXYtZTJBQUZtQ1JCTEUifQ.eyJpc3MiOiJ0cmFjazJfZnVsbCIsImlhdCI6MTcxOTQ3MzUxOSwiZXhwIjoxNzE5NTU5OTE5LCJqdGkiOiJvRmJGNXhhdnZLMTBRekJhIiwiYXVkIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly90cmlhbC5hdXRobGV0ZS5uZXQifQ.TXeCcijI8tICBH1bhOcNYTof9D0vDKAlu9Y0rl21EnPkUOCcsohiI8K7B1MlP1z82oC0LlYywXpcZ_gNnAC8BQ

The following is the base64url-decoded header and payload of the JWT. You can see that the client’s identifier is used as the value of the iss claim and the authorization server’s identifier is specified as the value of the aud claim.

{
  "typ": "JWT",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "kid": "7yNhIHVeaPFIB_0k-YpiFATomCLpxIv-e2AAFmCRBLE"
}

{
  "iss": "track2_full",
  "iat": 1719473519,
  "exp": 1719559919,
  "jti": "oFbF5xavvK10QzBa",
  "aud": "https://trial.authlete.net"
}

4.5.2.3. Step 3 : DPoP Proof JWT for PAR Request

To generate a DPoP Proof JWT, the generate-dpop-proof script in the oid4vci-demo repository can be used. With the key for DPoP demo (dpop.jwk) in the oid4vci-demo repository, the script can be invoked like below.

./generate-dpop-proof -k dpop.jwk -m POST \
    -u https://trial.authlete.net/api/par

The -u option (the short version of the --htu option) of the generate-dpop-proof script specifies the value of the htu claim in the DPoP Proof JWT.Because the DPoP Proof JWT being created here is for the PAR request, the URL of the PAR endpoint (https://trial.authlete.net/api/par) is specified by the -u option.

The generate-dpop-proof script generates a DPoP Proof JWT in the JWT format like below:

eyJ0eXAiOiJkcG9wK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiaEdmcXpHWGdhbzFRZ1ZJVFk2a2lIWU9LYmFMWEJ4VHFQSmE0RU9pbXhoSSIsInkiOiJFMUtpQV9mQTJ4OElycnlzb0dkbkJUTUI1LW8zRUpUX01nUUFfSG1HdTlNIn19.eyJqdGkiOiJxMWZJS21ad2FMNHlna1JQIiwiaHRtIjoiUE9TVCIsImh0dSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vdHJpYWwuYXV0aGxldGUubmV0L2FwaS9wYXIiLCJpYXQiOjE3MTk0NzQ2MzZ9.K8Mp44eK586UNCE-63bt5-m0v8B8KV840lDBe_5h2wLBcNWceS5x2fbFh9Koe7V7Rrbn6VT_hnCF8jYqkt6-dg

The following is the base64url-decoded header and payload of the DPoP Proof JWT. The htu claim holds the URL of the PAR endpoint.

{
  "typ": "dpop+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "hGfqzGXgao1QgVITY6kiHYOKbaLXBxTqPJa4EOimxhI",
    "y": "E1KiA_fA2x8IrrysoGdnBTMB5-o3EJT_MgQA_HmGu9M"
  }
}

{
  "jti": "q1fIKmZwaL4ygkRP",
  "htm": "POST",
  "htu": "https://trial.authlete.net/api/par",
  "iat": 1719474636
}

4.5.2.4. Step 4 : PAR Request

One of the advantages of the PAR endpoint over the authorization endpoint is that the PAR endpoint can perform client authentication. In this demo, we use attestation-based client authentication when accessing the PAR endpoint. The client authentication method requires that two JWTs, namely, a client attestation and a client attestation PoP, be specified by two HTTP headers, OAuth-Client-Attestation and OAuth-Client-Attestation-PoP. With the client attestation and the client attestation PoP you created in Step 2, and the DPoP Proof JWT you created in Step 3, you can make a PAR request by executing the following command. Please replace ${CLIENT_ATTESTATION}, ${CLIENT_ATTESTATION_POP}, ${DPOP_PROOF_JWT_FOR_PAR_REQUEST} and ${CODE_CHALLENGE} in the command line with the actual values you created in the previous steps.

curl -s https://trial.authlete.net/api/par \
     -H "OAuth-Client-Attestation: ${CLIENT_ATTESTATION}" \
     -H "OAuth-Client-Attestation-PoP: ${CLIENT_ATTESTATION_POP}" \
     -H "DPoP: ${DPOP_PROOF_JWT_FOR_PAR_REQUEST}" \
     -d client_id=track2_full \
     -d response_type=code \
     -d redirect_uri=https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection \
     -d scope=potential.track2.full.profile \
     -d code_challenge=${CODE_CHALLENGE} \
     -d code_challenge_method=S256

The PAR endpoint will return JSON as a response like below. In a successful case, the JSON contains the request_uri property. The value of this property is a request URI that represents the pre-registered authorization request.

{
  "expires_in": 600,
  "request_uri": "urn:ietf:params:oauth:request_uri:-CYpNdxTlS3S7e0PQKJVehPMnC0iiIk4pqJpD25k0Ws"
}

In this example, the value of the request URI is urn:ietf:params:oauth:request_uri:-CYpNdxTlS3S7e0PQKJVehPMnC0iiIk4pqJpD25k0Ws. You are expected to specify this value as the value of the request_uri parameter of the authorization request that you will make in the next step.

4.5.2.5. Step 5 : Authorization Request

Please input the following URL in the address bar of your web browser. This is an authorization request to the authorization endpoint of the authorization server. Don’t forget to replace ${REQUEST_URI} in the URL with the actual value of the request URI you obtained in the previous step.

https://trial.authlete.net/api/authorization?client_id=track2_full&request_uri=${REQUEST_URI}

The authorization endpoint will return an authorization page like below. In the page, input inga and inga as Login ID and Password, and then click the “Authorize” button.

Potential Track2 Full Authorization Page

You will be redirected to the redirection endpoint (cf. RFC 6749, 3.1.2).

Potential Track2 Full Redirection Endpoint

This redirection endpoint displays key-value pairs that it has received. The value of the code parameter displayed there is the issued authorization code. In this example, the value of the authorization code is yn1W7SLX9OEGqFZ2D986iPowVnoQtIRpPByBEyiIrBk. The authorization code will be used in the token request you will make later.

4.5.2.6. Step 6 : DPoP Proof JWT for Token Request

You need to create a new DPoP Proof JWT to access the token endpoint. You cannot reuse the DPoP Proof JWT you created for the PAR request. The following command line can generate the DPoP Proof JWT. Please note that the value of the -u option is the URL of the token endpoint (not the PAR endpoint).

./generate-dpop-proof -k dpop.jwk -m POST \
    -u https://trial.authlete.net/api/token

The generate-dpop-proof script will generate a JWT like below.

eyJ0eXAiOiJkcG9wK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiaEdmcXpHWGdhbzFRZ1ZJVFk2a2lIWU9LYmFMWEJ4VHFQSmE0RU9pbXhoSSIsInkiOiJFMUtpQV9mQTJ4OElycnlzb0dkbkJUTUI1LW8zRUpUX01nUUFfSG1HdTlNIn19.eyJqdGkiOiJFYzVhdklIcTN5Q25pUUFNIiwiaHRtIjoiUE9TVCIsImh0dSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vdHJpYWwuYXV0aGxldGUubmV0L2FwaS90b2tlbiIsImlhdCI6MTcxOTQ3NTAxNX0.0ahIcVPSpMY-g-_SfkB8C84wDhalE1FLfobyDciBoFv16W82gMIuoBw3kDIhHmGJAxxOVKOyTQFKMi25c30vlw

The following is the base64url-decoded header and payload of the DPoP Proof JWT. The htu claim holds the URL of the token endpoint.

{
  "typ": "dpop+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "hGfqzGXgao1QgVITY6kiHYOKbaLXBxTqPJa4EOimxhI",
    "y": "E1KiA_fA2x8IrrysoGdnBTMB5-o3EJT_MgQA_HmGu9M"
  }
}

{
  "jti": "Ec5avIHq3yCniQAM",
  "htm": "POST",
  "htu": "https://trial.authlete.net/api/token",
  "iat": 1719475015
}

4.5.2.7. Step 7 : Token Request

Now you have the following:

Client Attestattion (JWT)
Client Attestation PoP (JWT)
DPoP Proof JWT for Token Request (JWT)
Authorization Code
Code Verifier

With these, you can make a token request as follows. Don’t forget to replace variables in the command line with the actual values you created in the previous steps.

curl -s https://trial.authlete.net/api/token \
     -H "OAuth-Client-Attestation: ${CLIENT_ATTESTATION}" \
     -H "OAuth-Client-Attestation-PoP: ${CLIENT_ATTESTATION_POP}" \
     -H "DPoP: ${DPOP_PROOF_JWT_FOR_TOKEN_REQUEST}" \
     -d client_id=track2_full \
     -d grant_type=authorization_code \
     -d code=${AUTHORIZATION_CODE} \
     -d redirect_uri=https://nextdev-api.authlete.net/api/mock/redirection \
     -d code_verifier=${CODE_VERIFIER}

The token endpoint will return JSON as a response like below.

{
  "access_token": "_aPAJGv3bnb8UoSbkBCP9XF0tnCHoLDGBc6chbFSWkg",
  "token_type": "DPoP",
  "expires_in": 86400,
  "scope": "potential.track2.full.profile",
  "refresh_token": "NPJv7yAu5YKT7a6qeWes4mL8exDx-bPruXDQE3p8u80",
  "c_nonce": "01bcC_9FtNM22wO9pnUqRkeFQuJNEE3sHA6M-oDnsHs",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 86400
}

The value of the access_token property is the issued access token. This needs to be included in the credential request you will make later. The value of the c_nonce property is the issued nonce. This value needs to be included in the JWT Key Proofs you will create in the next step.

4.5.2.8. Step 8 : JWT Key Proofs for Credential Request

In POTENTIAL’s Track 2 Full Profile, a new feature introduced by “OpenID4VCI PR 293: rework credential and batch credential endpoint” is used. This new feature enables a client application to request multiple verifiable credentials in a single credential request. To request multiple verifiable credentials, a credential request needs to include multiple key proofs. Therefore, here we are going to generate two JWT Key Proofs with different holder keys. The oid4vci-demo repository contains two holder keys, holder.jwk and holder2.jwk, for demo. With these keys and the generate-key-proof script, you can generate JWT Key Proofs as follows. Please replace ${C_NONCE} in the command lines with the actual value of the c_nonce property in the token response you received in the previous step before executing the command lines.

JWT_KEY_PROOF_1=`./generate-key-proof -i https://trial.authlete.net -k holder.jwk -c track2_full -n ${C_NONCE}`
JWT_KEY_PROOF_2=`./generate-key-proof -i https://trial.authlete.net -k holder2.jwk -c track2_full -n ${C_NONCE}`

The c_nonce property in a token response is optional, so the token response from your authorization server may not include this property. In that case, you cannot generate a valid key proof including c_nonce until you get a valid c_nonce from your credential issuer.When the c_nonce included in a key proof is invalid, the credential issuer will include a valid c_nonce in the error response. With the c_nonce, you can generate a valid key proof.These steps described above imply that, if your authorization server does not include c_nonce in a token response, your first credential request with a key proof including a (fake) c_nonce inevitably fails. Although you know the first request will fail, you need to make the request only to get a valid c_nonce.The c_nonce property in a token response is optional, so authorization server implementations don’t have to include the property in a token response if they don’t want to. However, there are several people in the industry who dislike the feature that allows authorization servers to issue c_nonce and are attempting to remove this feature itself from the OID4VCI specification. If their attempt succeeded, all initial credential requests containing a key proof with c_nonce worldwide would inevitably fail.Authlete will continue to support the c_nonce property in a token response for harmless backward compatibility with Implementer’s Draft 1 of the OID4VCI specification, unless the specification is revised to explicitly prohibit including the property. However, introducing such prohibition would conflict with RFC 6749, the core specification of OAuth 2.0, which allows token responses to include arbitrary response parameters.

The following is an example of JWT Key Proof with holder.jwk. Please note that the content of the jwk claim in the header holds the public key corresponding to the private key in holder.jwk.

eyJ0eXAiOiJvcGVuaWQ0dmNpLXByb29mK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiUFN4UXJEMnpsMF9tWGNBcXoxbWdxU2VCb0Jobm14Mnl4QkVwckJZOEYyMCIsInkiOiJ4VjhmYmkxRlNvc1V1bkxldUxOdUxrSmlxbVk2VEtpTW51ci1HbjJ3UjEwIn19.eyJpc3MiOiJ0cmFjazJfZnVsbCIsImF1ZCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vdHJpYWwuYXV0aGxldGUubmV0IiwiaWF0IjoxNzE5NDc2Mjg4LCJub25jZSI6IjAxYmNDXzlGdE5NMjJ3TzlwblVxUmtlRlF1Sk5FRTNzSEE2TS1vRG5zSHMifQ.lgI038MOL6DtbDnPOa8GZen0d2EoiZ-dgn_IU9hJYe5aWxL81hADNOS6v7ChJ9zxcU90sPDEJEyM12tDVm7VPQ

{
  "typ": "openid4vci-proof+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "PSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20",
    "y": "xV8fbi1FSosUunLeuLNuLkJiqmY6TKiMnur-Gn2wR10"
  }
}

{
  "iss": "track2_full",
  "aud": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "iat": 1719476288,
  "nonce": "01bcC_9FtNM22wO9pnUqRkeFQuJNEE3sHA6M-oDnsHs"
}

Likewise, the following is an example of JWT Key Proof with holder2.jwk. The jwk claim in the header is the public key corresponding to the private key in holder2.jwk.

eyJ0eXAiOiJvcGVuaWQ0dmNpLXByb29mK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiSkotN2YwQXNRNWZJUmRxaDJySXoxSS02SkpBTUowQjUzM1Iybm8tRmtfQSIsInkiOiJ6LTFFZnc2ZmRoZ2RLVEZISVhOSDI5bV9UTlpjWUpDLUxDSVU2WWRQdFI4In19.eyJpc3MiOiJ0cmFjazJfZnVsbCIsImF1ZCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vdHJpYWwuYXV0aGxldGUubmV0IiwiaWF0IjoxNzE5NDc2MzAwLCJub25jZSI6IjAxYmNDXzlGdE5NMjJ3TzlwblVxUmtlRlF1Sk5FRTNzSEE2TS1vRG5zSHMifQ.nNGWEYSDvH_B632TF_Z_ecG14fzmBR6QTjQS3Irjp5xiPLkHtm_XXGvKFeVLTc8erZpmWPvD_2e99DUvDsajyA

{
  "typ": "openid4vci-proof+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "JJ-7f0AsQ5fIRdqh2rIz1I-6JJAMJ0B533R2no-Fk_A",
    "y": "z-1Efw6fdhgdKTFHIXNH29m_TNZcYJC-LCIU6YdPtR8"
  }
}

{
  "iss": "track2_full",
  "aud": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "iat": 1719476300,
  "nonce": "01bcC_9FtNM22wO9pnUqRkeFQuJNEE3sHA6M-oDnsHs"
}

4.5.2.9. Step 9 : DPoP Proof JWT for Credential Request

You need to create another DPoP Proof JWT again to access the credential endpoint. In addition to specifying the URL of the credential endpoint as the value of the -u option, this time you need to specify the access token value using the -a option (short for --at option). This option is necessary to include the ath claim in the DPoP Proof JWT.

./generate-dpop-proof -k dpop.jwk -m POST \
    -u https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential \
    -a ${ACCESS_TOKEN}

The following is an example of DPoP Proof JWT for a credential request. Please note that the payload part includes the ath claim, which represents the hash value of the access token.

eyJ0eXAiOiJkcG9wK2p3dCIsImFsZyI6IkVTMjU2IiwiandrIjp7ImNydiI6IlAtMjU2Iiwia3R5IjoiRUMiLCJ4IjoiaEdmcXpHWGdhbzFRZ1ZJVFk2a2lIWU9LYmFMWEJ4VHFQSmE0RU9pbXhoSSIsInkiOiJFMUtpQV9mQTJ4OElycnlzb0dkbkJUTUI1LW8zRUpUX01nUUFfSG1HdTlNIn19.eyJqdGkiOiI3Vm9zZW1YZ3ZLNUpVMVI0IiwiaHRtIjoiUE9TVCIsImh0dSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vdHJpYWwuYXV0aGxldGUubmV0L2FwaS9jcmVkZW50aWFsIiwiaWF0IjoxNzE5NDc2ODQxLCJhdGgiOiIzQWV6TzBZMTFnZzgwVm5Zd3puLUpDbXFNVnZkc2pJZXlBMTRoc1BOdHVvIn0.zDZYZdgb2jo4KKM0_OariZK0yrEcIFmPdpImX0Q-pttqw8480-nVdW-lQlQqQvcMtDKEWwZtgcNTsNExgomZ2g

{
  "typ": "dpop+jwt",
  "alg": "ES256",
  "jwk": {
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kty": "EC",
    "x": "hGfqzGXgao1QgVITY6kiHYOKbaLXBxTqPJa4EOimxhI",
    "y": "E1KiA_fA2x8IrrysoGdnBTMB5-o3EJT_MgQA_HmGu9M"
  }
}

{
  "jti": "7VosemXgvK5JU1R4",
  "htm": "POST",
  "htu": "https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential",
  "iat": 1719476841,
  "ath": "3AezO0Y11gg80VnYwzn-JCmqMVvdsjIeyA14hsPNtuo"
}

4.5.2.10. Step 10 : Credential Request

Now you have the following:

Access Token
DPoP Proof JWT for Credential Request (JWT)
JWT Key Proof 1 (JWT)
JWT Key Proof 2 (JWT)

With these, you can make a credential request as follows.

curl -s https://trial.authlete.net/api/credential \
     -H "Authorization: Bearer ${ACCESS_TOKEN}" \
     -H "DPoP: ${DPOP_PROOF_JWT_FOR_CREDENTIAL_REQUEST}" \
     -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
       --data '{
  "format": "vc+sd-jwt",
  "vct": "urn:eu.europa.ec.eudi:pid:1",
  "proofs": {
    "jwt": [
      "'${JWT_KEY_PROOF_1}'",
      "'${JWT_KEY_PROOF_2}'"
    ]
  }
}'

The key point here is that the message body of the credential request contains the proofs property instead of the proof property. The proofs property is a new addition introduced by OpenID4VCI PR 293, which enables the inclusion of multiple key proofs. The credential endpoint will return a response like below.

{
  "credentials": [
    "eyJraWQiOiJKMUZ3SlA4N0M2LVFOX1dTSU9tSkFRYzZuNUNRX2JaZGFGSjVHRG5XMVJrIiwidHlwIjoidmMrc2Qtand0IiwiYWxnIjoiRVMyNTYifQ.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.dlnBVF7xd9uFbaUS0ExMHN-62uOnmzAmGSNOYJrP3jNNpV1ihmu02hdDTFEFuhhMQ2DXeKYG3mnbYZ4gjQogVw~WyJubFJHOFlwVXRyWlZybnZMaGsxVVNRIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd~WyJ1U0pTVHhqZHBKLVZKYzVJTTY3cHNnIiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd~WyJtWFg5ZHBLNHFZWC16WHRuczdnb2tnIiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ~WyJ0Q0NxOUNvWHJRTjJSY3FoY1dUTG9nIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd~WyJlQU1BaG51QlAxQTY4Und3YU9YUU13IiwiMTgiLHRydWVd~WyJ0MVJ2YS1jeTVLQS0xT1hYQW93ZklRIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd~WyJpNXJNNDVZdjN1WHplRnZEekpxbjdnIiwiZm9ybWF0dGVkIiwiMTE0IE9sZCBTdGF0ZSBId3kgMTI3LCBTaG9zaG9uZSwgQ0EgOTIzODQsIFVTQSJd~WyJvaFhiOVdFQTdHTmc0SEVrem9yVG5BIiwic3RyZWV0X2FkZHJlc3MiLCIxMTQgT2xkIFN0YXRlIEh3eSAxMjciXQ~WyJFdmY1dkhCRFc4RmgzQk84SnZNOHR3IiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd~WyIyZFJVWFBfajlIUF9nX1VFYTZRVkh3IiwicG9zdGFsX2NvZGUiLCJDQSA5MjM4NCJd~WyJSbmNCeVBRdW5NbTNtb3hDRnVaOFpRIiwiY291bnRyeSIsIlVTQSJd~WyI1NmJLM1BKcG1wZ1kzdlA4WHNUYnZnIiwiaXNzdWluZ19hdXRob3JpdHkiLCJVUyJd~WyJjdXNabVM1MHVteUk3ZWc2SGhJYWNnIiwiaXNzdWluZ19jb3VudHJ5IiwiVVMiXQ~",
    "eyJraWQiOiJKMUZ3SlA4N0M2LVFOX1dTSU9tSkFRYzZuNUNRX2JaZGFGSjVHRG5XMVJrIiwidHlwIjoidmMrc2Qtand0IiwiYWxnIjoiRVMyNTYifQ.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.oI6tgincnKaRqACfYe46PweL1kvbrbjJcnwKnBtGDpUfWbvRTj2B8pn4JWVQ2XPBDEnAJaeO0tJ7B1U1infWMA~WyJBMFYzTDlwdzQ3U1BfSk5XYTVFOGhBIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd~WyJLZy1VTFN4N2JlOGRlYm5yMngyVjRnIiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd~WyJZLUVCUkw0OTJyUm54T3BGaWtUOE1BIiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ~WyJreUFTdHg1SWNUaXVfQ3RNdTBDck5RIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd~WyI4WGJCNGRRZENZbkh6a3BuR094YU1RIiwiMTgiLHRydWVd~WyJYM0RBUHdFWTRGaEQ2UUNNSU5idXBnIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd~WyJ3SDhKTE5tc1dkcVdfZ3Q3RmtQbGpRIiwiZm9ybWF0dGVkIiwiMTE0IE9sZCBTdGF0ZSBId3kgMTI3LCBTaG9zaG9uZSwgQ0EgOTIzODQsIFVTQSJd~WyJEVUJaRXNkWVVPREhoZTJ3TUxFMnpBIiwic3RyZWV0X2FkZHJlc3MiLCIxMTQgT2xkIFN0YXRlIEh3eSAxMjciXQ~WyJ6dXQzd0pnbjN1MExCcTJRNTlXZEFRIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd~WyJsVzdXQTkxakRON1RGWkpRRzJNUi1BIiwicG9zdGFsX2NvZGUiLCJDQSA5MjM4NCJd~WyJlczdiUHpNeXdNaXJON0tzemtpMFdRIiwiY291bnRyeSIsIlVTQSJd~WyJtOEVlUUM2akhIeUlSWGVDQXhERi1nIiwiaXNzdWluZ19hdXRob3JpdHkiLCJVUyJd~WyIxMzhhaHkwMVdvNFFxekZyNFlpSld3IiwiaXNzdWluZ19jb3VudHJ5IiwiVVMiXQ~"
  ],
  "c_nonce": "01bcC_9FtNM22wO9pnUqRkeFQuJNEE3sHA6M-oDnsHs",
  "c_nonce_expires_in": 84589
}

In a successful case, the response contains the credentials property instead of the credential property. Elements in the credentials array are issued verifiable credentials. In this example, the credentials array contains two verifiable credentials because the credential request contained two key proofs. The format of the verifiable credentials is SD-JWT. They can be decoded using the decode-sd-jwt script in the oid4vci-demo repository. The first verifiable credetial is decoded as follows:

{
  "kid": "J1FwJP87C6-QN_WSIOmJAQc6n5CQ_bZdaFJ5GDnW1Rk",
  "typ": "vc+sd-jwt",
  "alg": "ES256"
}
{
  "place_of_birth": {
    "_sd": [
      "NEWkVX88jhCo1UEgFbNKP6626EaUzzNWBG7HwUY8V8U",
      "T_iK7PoHH4_jSAZGZ1Ycmw6rIvdM_3ZGLZLWBqQ6B98"
    ]
  },
  "_sd": [
    "-9cF6ruNASG7L_OgtGSfXR_JCOUfCzdVazuPvDQlWqg",
    "1wU07sttv6pL7aGj_yb2ygKjUASyVi-Y5qLOqh37vOA",
    "4uL_-hxPMJIO5Yu7pNn0mOyHBAZ5lGG0aca3jYho8pU",
    "7uFWWNoADeMJsW1frxbT5xs9G3xxC-0IdXLewDNrXlg",
    "9_6cxL1seG51EWbf9Nr1HfIiE5ij7gYON6YqEwj8iyI",
    "9cZBEQDXQ66DhjwRO1HsqvN-PKDtnanAZY6Am7iu10I",
    "ANTGpFdiy6pZb_7ooZWBd-UYFPtwd4b44WqnVxe1B1A",
    "BBSMM7ewXokwqWRcYCRiKk2smmi5gk3NMSmD2ZN6ySs",
    "P8Xm31CTIswS5S6QrbK-sk_sWSPc-fbnXc6sU_1JCFE",
    "TrDpaVqrzRUl_3I-z14IkYvlDfwScgcmr9R-fhFcqXE",
    "ezODKMvCFYoDGg4mcKDRuW2OziLjixV4JFCQKFzBtlM",
    "m2bdi8sOpHQe8553ajbXA3pjCSG3tB8xOuoiCyyYUbc",
    "utmrilRXgSDplnQdunNS6vbo18PvrKl6xDkksTVwauY",
    "xJ3KsNjn_hYzi3LZVHL0hFINYWE3q-eRhEGFEeTBPH8"
  ],
  "address": {
    "_sd": [
      "3Q1UvMFlitTV13A07Mzf27S6_UmMkbDTP_kCwFIdNRg",
      "A834oLNV5tEOoG6yS-FtE3AajTtP_FWUaQxA9gGUygY",
      "FQtnL-pZVCQQHQCV7MYz3HpiJN_RHFfNl9UJk7Hh0MI",
      "GUlsr0iqILMY5Ay8NyY31bs3dwSjvFkwOZdt1FTuBwg",
      "Iy5LAa-Q-48d1cvwEC7uqb0D0TyVlV_itvHsrMJdMTw",
      "LsbPsLh87AbSwpzYXFgSFvY4sELWYepvKBsySAEla1w",
      "UfQ4BKQGffd_pSUBbGuEBP3gzFos5OlLSo1IqwY4MlI",
      "V4-E76WSJR0n1MqdwllISNj1hKgDg8wOjtIrjnkCkYg",
      "XRfCEe5Os-JpS99QWcZjD_nut7wBpsD3_WcZ6ujhlx0",
      "iCNXk7L-472vgRj6GDCgDjXNRQPJis8jbSoyQWOJD-A",
      "nG9-F8D5OefY6gKBlUIMVtPZeyn_AHHhf36HG3fCkV4",
      "pXbRSQ1_xSTaHHF4ahQ3dVOzt5827NF1kFKRkgPGwqU"
    ]
  },
  "vct": "urn:eu.europa.ec.eudi:pid:1",
  "_sd_alg": "sha-256",
  "iss": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "cnf": {
    "jwk": {
      "kty": "EC",
      "crv": "P-256",
      "kid": "4M9kIrB9WYzt1GQgL12lzdBZsGyeV3lgPKov28oT5L4",
      "x": "PSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20",
      "y": "xV8fbi1FSosUunLeuLNuLkJiqmY6TKiMnur-Gn2wR10"
    }
  },
  "iat": 1719476855,
  "age_equal_or_over": {
    "_sd": [
      "KZOg8CPCUZB8N_9d-XMUoCKXClSlHw4pbNiE8A8399g",
      "ffgi_NhUWBVmSbgryZkk1zRvhI5rGB1awgbOfbD-heM"
    ]
  }
}
{
  "digest": "4uL_-hxPMJIO5Yu7pNn0mOyHBAZ5lGG0aca3jYho8pU",
  "WyJubFJHOFlwVXRyWlZybnZMaGsxVVNRIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd": [
    "nlRG8YpUtrZVrnvLhk1USQ",
    "sub",
    "1004"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "9_6cxL1seG51EWbf9Nr1HfIiE5ij7gYON6YqEwj8iyI",
  "WyJ1U0pTVHhqZHBKLVZKYzVJTTY3cHNnIiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd": [
    "uSJSTxjdpJ-VJc5IM67psg",
    "family_name",
    "Silverstone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "m2bdi8sOpHQe8553ajbXA3pjCSG3tB8xOuoiCyyYUbc",
  "WyJtWFg5ZHBLNHFZWC16WHRuczdnb2tnIiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ": [
    "mXX9dpK4qYX-zXtns7gokg",
    "given_name",
    "Inga"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "BBSMM7ewXokwqWRcYCRiKk2smmi5gk3NMSmD2ZN6ySs",
  "WyJ0Q0NxOUNvWHJRTjJSY3FoY1dUTG9nIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd": [
    "tCCq9CoXrQN2RcqhcWTLog",
    "birthdate",
    "1991-11-06"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "KZOg8CPCUZB8N_9d-XMUoCKXClSlHw4pbNiE8A8399g",
  "WyJlQU1BaG51QlAxQTY4Und3YU9YUU13IiwiMTgiLHRydWVd": [
    "eAMAhnuBP1A68RwwaOXQMw",
    "18",
    true
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "T_iK7PoHH4_jSAZGZ1Ycmw6rIvdM_3ZGLZLWBqQ6B98",
  "WyJ0MVJ2YS1jeTVLQS0xT1hYQW93ZklRIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd": [
    "t1Rva-cy5KA-1OXXAowfIQ",
    "locality",
    "Shoshone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "V4-E76WSJR0n1MqdwllISNj1hKgDg8wOjtIrjnkCkYg",
  "WyJpNXJNNDVZdjN1WHplRnZEekpxbjdnIiwiZm9ybWF0dGVkIiwiMTE0IE9sZCBTdGF0ZSBId3kgMTI3LCBTaG9zaG9uZSwgQ0EgOTIzODQsIFVTQSJd": [
    "i5rM45Yv3uXzeFvDzJqn7g",
    "formatted",
    "114 Old State Hwy 127, Shoshone, CA 92384, USA"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "nG9-F8D5OefY6gKBlUIMVtPZeyn_AHHhf36HG3fCkV4",
  "WyJvaFhiOVdFQTdHTmc0SEVrem9yVG5BIiwic3RyZWV0X2FkZHJlc3MiLCIxMTQgT2xkIFN0YXRlIEh3eSAxMjciXQ": [
    "ohXb9WEA7GNg4HEkzorTnA",
    "street_address",
    "114 Old State Hwy 127"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "GUlsr0iqILMY5Ay8NyY31bs3dwSjvFkwOZdt1FTuBwg",
  "WyJFdmY1dkhCRFc4RmgzQk84SnZNOHR3IiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd": [
    "Evf5vHBDW8Fh3BO8JvM8tw",
    "locality",
    "Shoshone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "LsbPsLh87AbSwpzYXFgSFvY4sELWYepvKBsySAEla1w",
  "WyIyZFJVWFBfajlIUF9nX1VFYTZRVkh3IiwicG9zdGFsX2NvZGUiLCJDQSA5MjM4NCJd": [
    "2dRUXP_j9HP_g_UEa6QVHw",
    "postal_code",
    "CA 92384"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "XRfCEe5Os-JpS99QWcZjD_nut7wBpsD3_WcZ6ujhlx0",
  "WyJSbmNCeVBRdW5NbTNtb3hDRnVaOFpRIiwiY291bnRyeSIsIlVTQSJd": [
    "RncByPQunMm3moxCFuZ8ZQ",
    "country",
    "USA"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "utmrilRXgSDplnQdunNS6vbo18PvrKl6xDkksTVwauY",
  "WyI1NmJLM1BKcG1wZ1kzdlA4WHNUYnZnIiwiaXNzdWluZ19hdXRob3JpdHkiLCJVUyJd": [
    "56bK3PJpmpgY3vP8XsTbvg",
    "issuing_authority",
    "US"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "ezODKMvCFYoDGg4mcKDRuW2OziLjixV4JFCQKFzBtlM",
  "WyJjdXNabVM1MHVteUk3ZWc2SGhJYWNnIiwiaXNzdWluZ19jb3VudHJ5IiwiVVMiXQ": [
    "cusZmS50umyI7eg6HhIacg",
    "issuing_country",
    "US"
  ]
}

The key point here is that the value of the cnf.jwk property matches the public key embedded in the first key proof.

"cnf": {
  "jwk": {
    "kty": "EC",
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kid": "4M9kIrB9WYzt1GQgL12lzdBZsGyeV3lgPKov28oT5L4",
    "x": "PSxQrD2zl0_mXcAqz1mgqSeBoBhnmx2yxBEprBY8F20",
    "y": "xV8fbi1FSosUunLeuLNuLkJiqmY6TKiMnur-Gn2wR10"
  }
}

Likewise, the second verifiable credential is decoded as follows:

{
  "kid": "J1FwJP87C6-QN_WSIOmJAQc6n5CQ_bZdaFJ5GDnW1Rk",
  "typ": "vc+sd-jwt",
  "alg": "ES256"
}
{
  "place_of_birth": {
    "_sd": [
      "IwmjQMwtNNOgVByenkaf1zdrbsR-illZm7zG6aozmMU",
      "SqSnQoAgmbjKwdW0M08oVu_vKK-i5mP7DsU6ypw1Nzs"
    ]
  },
  "_sd": [
    "3qyJcInMTE8VmoAPt5MRcmuDDapTL_AJdGlcqS7IEPE",
    "6J-ld9Ky-CxTIxjnyF6v3_BKj52GMFCxgt_AJvINsQU",
    "6kcwpvDBgNCVE33dgRgyb2upDA5n9MFa5-kkZaJFse4",
    "DX4IOHFUEhT6o6SjO5hPfbyGOosfp-GV8MvldfuvirY",
    "Eb-0mOFCFYebWeOcuM6kPEaiDXxNvDLPjr93o3Q9Jis",
    "IKO9y8FvNYiLdiaEpOHAejXDaX1WWyTORtTvv7iIS-M",
    "IKT04dqgSa3PziIMedmSCNY9z24opA3Fhz-e0m7qWEY",
    "IyHzhcH7i3sdK_6KEIIgCiY3EgC9PTiNscWiwPFKqGk",
    "JMyx8C4ajLUO3KGsSD2hnC1qBiI_4I8esd1d3ersLSk",
    "SQC3IBC2ZaVPBdU4Bf2eFHpUCR2ZEMnfAPQmN2ekiio",
    "XEIVj8_cWJ4AWSwq6V2ZNnP9gr_iU5qBdplSAr0t-I8",
    "Z45vc3_ZqI6RMF7LZhNWeZvbR0EP75Cm-wMqEnJGZVA",
    "_F6VLNzu3wqSS8pQWZyyzN-TrlFV_Xy-zuZcQl1VwcQ",
    "ayvRUSvg8ksy2y4B8FRMz4lhMWrXTdpUYOjtiYgUQDQ",
    "g8R8afpQTDseQdf6jmr_LchULTseuzruIlTUie4TWV0",
    "gwipMBDHTCjql0ytoW6v7APj5VnlmZLMl2RSXeVSEwI",
    "hBxQxjOt0C3xIJYbcOhRpSf9j6cJm0E3hQNVTSOOz2A",
    "l5RFyERQPtE-LzkdEPhWyz4wmyw1F-MQI0Av1HdDz4E",
    "q4vW4tK4d2u-ody2l3m6_jbmx5ZSRiUO5G7Ip13NJ1w",
    "uXiO47XWWlGPDa6q-sJNPsDzLwWLli1427cP6A3C3HU",
    "yBoPxiDnZ5aigIv5YzOU112AWGOpUiSCF3Jdx2v6Dt8",
    "zOQ6jU7_Ox07qYqIJ7oW216bbQdsmy_AyGq0imnnyAc"
  ],
  "address": {
    "_sd": [
      "2CviwUz5xL0RYFsPaHYYxUJUx0cOoDXBaIlfsoXrhzo",
      "56k05jWNcZ-EpgYhh3cRpDJ8nJEW8-8ZqoIcrXUbpAM",
      "7wyr7x39o2SzV7trbuICxwLjMPbiwQvu4xuG7OlALiY",
      "Jl8BoyDHMy1yZJAa0DybSBsmBRgXEUOEQ41olpKon8w",
      "KsXxsBHYo_owUkbxVUQOFcPth9ejDnAg8caSWAWxGaI",
      "Yzluf4m4Ltah0Eshk3CF7iS-q2tRm2iW_UuYicmO9Ks",
      "n-jVZHE6d3t85ZCPWa1NBnJMSEt80yOL1JatQueXfwo",
      "omAxklUKrr2Ol5ogFY6XgI-Xm4v63UkVb1_OWaXkkEQ",
      "wWBkWPeMRuGF3b6KGkBxrxgYckjW3qPDDOtr9PNwCbE"
    ]
  },
  "vct": "urn:eu.europa.ec.eudi:pid:1",
  "_sd_alg": "sha-256",
  "iss": "https://trial.authlete.net",
  "cnf": {
    "jwk": {
      "kty": "EC",
      "crv": "P-256",
      "kid": "B8os8dNBM1viONYOzOHfPKJwp3SGlMYKSNACSWuZRqs",
      "x": "JJ-7f0AsQ5fIRdqh2rIz1I-6JJAMJ0B533R2no-Fk_A",
      "y": "z-1Efw6fdhgdKTFHIXNH29m_TNZcYJC-LCIU6YdPtR8"
    }
  },
  "iat": 1719476855,
  "age_equal_or_over": {
    "_sd": [
      "I8GGGeWArEG00Pqb5_jfBg0hXFwDOY9i4gmOYLju9-Y",
      "uHfl4bgM0Wb6a0VHu3YltaMfHduMvHo221UAQBd08XU"
    ]
  }
}
{
  "digest": "l5RFyERQPtE-LzkdEPhWyz4wmyw1F-MQI0Av1HdDz4E",
  "WyJBMFYzTDlwdzQ3U1BfSk5XYTVFOGhBIiwic3ViIiwiMTAwNCJd": [
    "A0V3L9pw47SP_JNWa5E8hA",
    "sub",
    "1004"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "IKT04dqgSa3PziIMedmSCNY9z24opA3Fhz-e0m7qWEY",
  "WyJLZy1VTFN4N2JlOGRlYm5yMngyVjRnIiwiZmFtaWx5X25hbWUiLCJTaWx2ZXJzdG9uZSJd": [
    "Kg-ULSx7be8debnr2x2V4g",
    "family_name",
    "Silverstone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "uXiO47XWWlGPDa6q-sJNPsDzLwWLli1427cP6A3C3HU",
  "WyJZLUVCUkw0OTJyUm54T3BGaWtUOE1BIiwiZ2l2ZW5fbmFtZSIsIkluZ2EiXQ": [
    "Y-EBRL492rRnxOpFikT8MA",
    "given_name",
    "Inga"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "zOQ6jU7_Ox07qYqIJ7oW216bbQdsmy_AyGq0imnnyAc",
  "WyJreUFTdHg1SWNUaXVfQ3RNdTBDck5RIiwiYmlydGhkYXRlIiwiMTk5MS0xMS0wNiJd": [
    "kyAStx5IcTiu_CtMu0CrNQ",
    "birthdate",
    "1991-11-06"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "uHfl4bgM0Wb6a0VHu3YltaMfHduMvHo221UAQBd08XU",
  "WyI4WGJCNGRRZENZbkh6a3BuR094YU1RIiwiMTgiLHRydWVd": [
    "8XbB4dQdCYnHzkpnGOxaMQ",
    "18",
    true
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "IwmjQMwtNNOgVByenkaf1zdrbsR-illZm7zG6aozmMU",
  "WyJYM0RBUHdFWTRGaEQ2UUNNSU5idXBnIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd": [
    "X3DAPwEY4FhD6QCMINbupg",
    "locality",
    "Shoshone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "7wyr7x39o2SzV7trbuICxwLjMPbiwQvu4xuG7OlALiY",
  "WyJ3SDhKTE5tc1dkcVdfZ3Q3RmtQbGpRIiwiZm9ybWF0dGVkIiwiMTE0IE9sZCBTdGF0ZSBId3kgMTI3LCBTaG9zaG9uZSwgQ0EgOTIzODQsIFVTQSJd": [
    "wH8JLNmsWdqW_gt7FkPljQ",
    "formatted",
    "114 Old State Hwy 127, Shoshone, CA 92384, USA"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "Jl8BoyDHMy1yZJAa0DybSBsmBRgXEUOEQ41olpKon8w",
  "WyJEVUJaRXNkWVVPREhoZTJ3TUxFMnpBIiwic3RyZWV0X2FkZHJlc3MiLCIxMTQgT2xkIFN0YXRlIEh3eSAxMjciXQ": [
    "DUBZEsdYUODHhe2wMLE2zA",
    "street_address",
    "114 Old State Hwy 127"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "wWBkWPeMRuGF3b6KGkBxrxgYckjW3qPDDOtr9PNwCbE",
  "WyJ6dXQzd0pnbjN1MExCcTJRNTlXZEFRIiwibG9jYWxpdHkiLCJTaG9zaG9uZSJd": [
    "zut3wJgn3u0LBq2Q59WdAQ",
    "locality",
    "Shoshone"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "n-jVZHE6d3t85ZCPWa1NBnJMSEt80yOL1JatQueXfwo",
  "WyJsVzdXQTkxakRON1RGWkpRRzJNUi1BIiwicG9zdGFsX2NvZGUiLCJDQSA5MjM4NCJd": [
    "lW7WA91jDN7TFZJQG2MR-A",
    "postal_code",
    "CA 92384"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "Yzluf4m4Ltah0Eshk3CF7iS-q2tRm2iW_UuYicmO9Ks",
  "WyJlczdiUHpNeXdNaXJON0tzemtpMFdRIiwiY291bnRyeSIsIlVTQSJd": [
    "es7bPzMywMirN7Kszki0WQ",
    "country",
    "USA"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "IyHzhcH7i3sdK_6KEIIgCiY3EgC9PTiNscWiwPFKqGk",
  "WyJtOEVlUUM2akhIeUlSWGVDQXhERi1nIiwiaXNzdWluZ19hdXRob3JpdHkiLCJVUyJd": [
    "m8EeQC6jHHyIRXeCAxDF-g",
    "issuing_authority",
    "US"
  ]
}
{
  "digest": "6J-ld9Ky-CxTIxjnyF6v3_BKj52GMFCxgt_AJvINsQU",
  "WyIxMzhhaHkwMVdvNFFxekZyNFlpSld3IiwiaXNzdWluZ19jb3VudHJ5IiwiVVMiXQ": [
    "138ahy01Wo4QqzFr4YiJWw",
    "issuing_country",
    "US"
  ]
}

You can see that the cnf.jwk property in the second verifiable credential matches the public key embedded in the second key proof.

"cnf": {
  "jwk": {
    "kty": "EC",
    "crv": "P-256",
    "kid": "B8os8dNBM1viONYOzOHfPKJwp3SGlMYKSNACSWuZRqs",
    "x": "JJ-7f0AsQ5fIRdqh2rIz1I-6JJAMJ0B533R2no-Fk_A",
    "y": "z-1Efw6fdhgdKTFHIXNH29m_TNZcYJC-LCIU6YdPtR8"
  }
}

Flows and Features

Implementation Details

Going Live

Integration

​1. Introduction

​2. OID4VCI Specification

​2.1. Core Technical Terms

​2.1.1. Verifiable Credential

​2.1.2. Credential Issuer

​2.1.3. Access Token

​2.1.4. Authorization Server

​2.1.5. Wallet

​2.1.6. Relationship

​2.2. Access Token Issuance Overview

​2.2.1. Pre-Authorized Code Flow

​2.2.2. Authorization Code Flow

​2.2.3. Authorization Code Flow + issuer_state

​2.2.4. Authorization Code Flow + authorization_details

​2.2.5. Authorization Code Flow + scope

​2.3. Credential Issuance Overview

​2.3.1. Deferred Credential Issuance

​2.3.2. Batch Credential Issuance

​2.4. Access Token Issuance Details

​2.4.1. Credential Offer

2.4.1.1. Credential Offer Issuance by Value

2.4.1.2. Credential Offer Issuance by Reference

2.4.1.3. Credential Offer Content

2.4.1.4. “credential_configuration_ids” in Credential Offer

​2.4.2. Pre-Authorized Code Flow Details

​2.4.3. Issuable Credentials

​2.5. Credential Verification

​2.5.1. Key Binding

​2.6. Selective Disclosure

​2.6.1. SD-JWT

​2.7. Verifiable Credential Formats

​2.7.1. Confusion Surrounding Verifiable Credential Formats

​2.7.2. Essential Functions of Verifiable Credential Formats

​2.7.3. SD-JWT VC

​2.7.4. Other Verifiable Credential Formats

​2.8. Credential Information for Access Token

​2.8.1. Credential Information in RAR Object

2.8.1.1. RAR Object with The credential_configuration_id Property

2.8.1.2. RAR Object with The format Property

​2.8.2. Credential Information in Credential Configuration

​2.9. Credential Issuance Details

​2.9.1. Key Proof

2.9.1.1. Key Proof JWT

2.9.1.2. Other Key Proofs

​2.9.2. c_nonce

​2.9.3. Credential Request

2.9.3.1. Credential Information in Credential Request

2.9.3.2. Key Proof Information in Credential Request

​2.9.4. Credential Response

2.9.4.1. Credential Response with Verifiable Credential

2.9.4.2. Credential Response with Transaction ID

2.9.4.3. Credential Response with Error

​2.9.5. Deferred Credential Request

​2.9.6. Deferred Credential Response

​2.9.7. Batch Credential Request

​2.9.8. Batch Credential Response

​2.10. Public Key Distribution

​2.10.1. Embedding X.509 Certificate

​2.10.2. Embedding within Entity Configuration

​2.10.3. jwt-vc-issuer

​2.11. Specification Summary

​3. OID4VCI Implementation

​3.1. Authlete Overview

​3.2. Authlete Configuration

​3.2.1. Authlete Version

​3.2.2. Authlete Server Configuration

​3.2.3. Authlete Service Configuration

​3.3. Authlete APIs

​3.3.1. Overall Picture of Authlete APIs for OID4VCI

​3.3.2. Authlete API Call

​3.4. Credential Offer Issuance

​3.4.1. The /vci/offer/create API

​3.4.2. The /vci/offer/info API

​3.4.3. Credential Offer Issuance Example

​3.5. Credential Endpoint Implementation

​3.5.1. Credential Issuance Order

1. Introduction

2. OID4VCI Specification

2.1. Core Technical Terms

2.1.1. Verifiable Credential

2.1.2. Credential Issuer

2.1.3. Access Token

2.1.4. Authorization Server

2.1.5. Wallet

2.1.6. Relationship

2.2. Access Token Issuance Overview

2.2.1. Pre-Authorized Code Flow

2.2.2. Authorization Code Flow

2.2.3. Authorization Code Flow + issuer_state

2.2.4. Authorization Code Flow + authorization_details

2.2.5. Authorization Code Flow + scope

2.3. Credential Issuance Overview

2.3.1. Deferred Credential Issuance

2.3.2. Batch Credential Issuance

2.4. Access Token Issuance Details

2.4.1. Credential Offer

2.4.2. Pre-Authorized Code Flow Details

2.4.3. Issuable Credentials

2.5. Credential Verification

2.5.1. Key Binding

2.6. Selective Disclosure

2.6.1. SD-JWT

2.7. Verifiable Credential Formats

2.7.1. Confusion Surrounding Verifiable Credential Formats

2.7.2. Essential Functions of Verifiable Credential Formats

2.7.3. SD-JWT VC

2.7.4. Other Verifiable Credential Formats

2.8. Credential Information for Access Token

2.8.1. Credential Information in RAR Object

2.8.1.1. RAR Object with The `credential_configuration_id` Property

2.8.1.2. RAR Object with The `format` Property

2.8.2. Credential Information in Credential Configuration

2.9. Credential Issuance Details

2.9.1. Key Proof

2.9.2. c_nonce

2.9.3. Credential Request

2.9.4. Credential Response

2.9.5. Deferred Credential Request

2.9.6. Deferred Credential Response

2.9.7. Batch Credential Request

2.9.8. Batch Credential Response

2.10. Public Key Distribution

2.10.1. Embedding X.509 Certificate

2.10.2. Embedding within Entity Configuration

2.10.3. jwt-vc-issuer

2.11. Specification Summary

3. OID4VCI Implementation

3.1. Authlete Overview

3.2. Authlete Configuration

3.2.1. Authlete Version

3.2.2. Authlete Server Configuration

3.2.3. Authlete Service Configuration

3.3. Authlete APIs

3.3.1. Overall Picture of Authlete APIs for OID4VCI

3.3.2. Authlete API Call

3.4. Credential Offer Issuance

3.4.1. The `/vci/offer/create` API

3.4.2. The `/vci/offer/info` API

3.4.3. Credential Offer Issuance Example

3.5. Credential Endpoint Implementation

3.5.1. Credential Issuance Order

3.6. Batch Credential Endpoint Implementation

3.7. Configure `oid4vci` in the Authlete Management Console

3.7.1. Service Settings

3.7.2. Client Settings

4. OID4VCI Demo

4.1. Pre-Authorized Code Flow + Key Proof + SD-JWT VC

4.1.1. Setup

4.1.2. Pre-Authorized Code

4.1.3. Access Token

4.1.4. Key Proof

4.1.5. SD-JWT VC

4.2. Authorization Code Flow + PAR + DPoP + mdoc

4.2.1. Setup

4.2.2. Request URI

4.2.3. Authorization Code